Here's the thing

[Guest Edgy DC]

If you're looking for a shortstop to pull up from the farm, the Mets are basically scrod. Jose Coronado had been the Buffalo shorstop most of the way so far, but he's been hitting something awful. Like lower OPS than Nick Evans awful. Now the Buffalo infield is Michel Abreu and a bunch of secondbasemen.

Andy Green --- Eight games, all at second, and on the DL since. Hasn't played more than 10 games at short since 2003.

Mike Lamb --- playing third and also not hitting a lick. A veteran of 936 big-league games, he's played everywhere on the field except pitcher.

And shortstop. He hasn't played there as a big leaguer either.

Jonathan Malo --- a 25-y.o. going-nowhere prospect, at least he's hovering around the interstate, which is better than most of the other options. But he also has but 13 games of shortstopping experience.

Argenis Reyes --- Battled through a 121 plate appearances last season with the Mets, but was ultimately proven to be over-exposed.

Ramon Martinez --- you remember him as a desperation stopgap secondbaseman during the Collapse of 2008. He's hitting OK --- a punchless .290 --- and has 260 games of big-league shorstopping experience. He's old, but he's looking like the only option.

At Bingo, 20-year-old Ruben Tejada is fighting for his starting job to the demoted Jose Coronado, so don't look there for help.

Still out there: Jose Valentin and Damion Easley. Both are presumably working on their barbecue skills and not in shape to play.

[Benjamin Grimm]

I'm thinking Ramon Martinez.

[soupcan]

What did I miss? Why are we talking about replacement shortstops?

Jose's injury more serious than first thought? I haven't read or seen that anywhere.

Cora's finger broke or something?

Edgy just worrying too much?

[Guest Edgy DC]

Edgy worrying after running out of shorstops due to injury early in yesterday's game. For all I know, Reyes and Cora will be 100% by the time they make LA, but running out of shortstops makes a man wonder who's next, and Martinez seems the lone opton.

In fact, I'd be surprised if they didn't at least sign a minor-league option.

[Ceetar]

Andy Green didn't look great in Spring (although he signed my ball)

if I ever see Argenis again, I might stop watching.

Ramon Martinez might be an okay guy.

Ruben Tejada impressed me, but I don't think he's ready to play at the major league level yet. (In fact, he didn't have a name on the back of his jersey, and wore either 86 or 87 depending on if it was available in the home/away color scheme) He always hasn't quite gotten comfortable turning a double play.



I think Reyes and Cora will probably be fine. I didn't listen to postgame stuff, but it seemed like they took Cora out just precautionarily. You'd think Reyes would be back, but I don't know what's going on there..

[smg58]

Hopefully nobody will be needed, but there's no disputing that the organization is thin at the position. Signing Valentin or Easley to a minor league deal doesn't sound like such a bad precautionary measure.

[G-Fafif]

Anybody seen Chris Woodward lately? Jorge Velandia? Luis Rivera?

Rey Ordonez, even with birth certificate adjusted, is under 40. And he couldn't have possibly lost anything off his offensive game. Can't lose what ya don't got.

[Ceetar]

="G-Fafif":1n59fpds]Anybody seen Chris Woodward lately? Jorge Velandia? Luis Rivera? Rey Ordonez, even with birth certificate adjusted, is under 40. And he couldn't have possibly lost anything off his offensive game. Can't lose what ya don't got.[/quote:1n59fpds] Couldn't hurt to have a '99 Mets connection on the team. (No, Steve Phillips on the broadcast last night doesn't count.) if this becomes an issue, they'll probably have some crazy fix. Like have Church play SS and put Murphy in right.

Frayed Knot May 18 2009 07:05 AM

Jerry is quoted in today's NYPost at being slightly concerned with the "slow healing" of Reyes's calf strain.

Nymr83 May 18 2009 07:40 AM

] Like have Church play SS doesnt he throw lefty?

Edgy DC May 18 2009 07:40 AM Edited 1 time(s), most recently on May 18 2009 09:38 AM

]Jerry is quoted in today's NYPost at being slightly concerned with the "slow healing" of Reyes's calf strain. That does it. He's been dead for two days, and they're sitting on the story.

RealityChuck May 18 2009 07:40 AM

="Ceetar":2rws4j9d]if this becomes an issue, they'll probably have some crazy fix. Like have Church play SS and put Murphy in right.[/quote:2rws4j9d]A left-handed throwing shortstop is not an idea whose time has come. Ceetar May 18 2009 07:42 AM ="RealityChuck":2qolk1xx] ="Ceetar":2qolk1xx]if this becomes an issue, they'll probably have some crazy fix. Like have Church play SS and put Murphy in right.[/quote:2qolk1xx]A left-handed throwing shortstop is not an idea whose time has come.[/quote:2qolk1xx] That won't stop them. Besides, if you asked Keith, i'm sure he'd tell you that a "Right-handed first baseman is not an idea whose time has come." ;-) Actually, is that why Murphy and Reed are the two guys Manuel decided to mention about playing 1B? And..I've always wondered this, but why does Delgado play 1B righty? or why does he bad Lefty? which is it?! Edgy DC May 18 2009 08:22 AM ="Ceetar":32kkfa9d]Actually, is that why Murphy and Reed are the two guys Manuel decided to mention about playing 1B?[/quote:32kkfa9d] Since Murphy hasn't played yet, and Reed is behind Tatis, I'll guess not. DocTee May 18 2009 08:49 AM Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position! Nymr83 May 18 2009 09:35 AM ="DocTee":1a1olmaw]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:1a1olmaw] 15 years, 45 lbs, and a dozen injections ago maybe. Gwreck May 18 2009 10:29 AM ="DocTee":2fu35ilo]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:2fu35ilo] Hey, by that token, the solution is to put Delgado (once healthy) back at Catcher and use Tatis at first. No need to put Schneider, Castro or Santos in the lineup. LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr May 18 2009 11:47 AM ="Gwreck":35na9z32] ="DocTee":35na9z32]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:35na9z32] Hey, by that token, the solution is to put Delgado (once healthy) back at Catcher and use Tatis at first. No need to put Schneider, Castro or Santos in the lineup.[/quote:35na9z32] Marketing slogan: "Just like 1986... minus all that annoying pitching!" Benjamin Grimm May 18 2009 11:50 AM You know, we'd all like to see Bobby Valentine come back. (I'm included in that group.) But I think I'd almost rather see Davey Johnson come back. I think he'd be a good for this particular team. Not at all likely to happen, of course, but if I were in charge, I'd consider reaching out to him. LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr May 18 2009 11:58 AM ="soupcan":30mmzwu6]What did I miss? Why are we talking about replacement shortstops? Jose's injury more serious than first thought? I haven't read or seen that anywhere. Cora's finger broke or something? Edgy just worrying too much?[/quote:30mmzwu6] Cora already sprained his left thumb during the game Saturday sliding after a double... then did the same to his right thumb last night in the first on the EXACT SAME PLAY. Headfirst slides and dumbshit plays make the Creepy Sun Baby cry. Ashie62 May 18 2009 02:38 PM Can Murphy learn short if Reyes is going on hiatus? Are we getting the Jose on DL after 9 days routine Elster88 May 18 2009 10:48 PM Two errors and some awful turns at the plate for Ramon. Early returns indicate he is not a major league shortstop. smg58 May 19 2009 06:56 AM I hope Minaya has Jose Valentin's number on speed dial. Elster88 May 19 2009 10:00 PM How many at-bats until Ramon Martinez gets his first hit? I say 25 or being sent back down to AAA, whichever comes first. Edgy DC May 22 2009 08:08 PM OK, time to talk shortstops. Part of me thinks Putz was held out because he's being dangled as trade bait. Tejada at Bingo: .236 / .301 / .356 // .657 in 36 games. Coronado at Bingo: .316 / .409 / .474 // .883 in six games, but... Coronado at Buff: .141 / .240 / .165 // .404 in 29 games. Gun to my head, I go with Jose over Ruben, but... John Cougar Lunchbucket May 22 2009 08:14 PM Edited 2 time(s), most recently on May 22 2009 08:18 PM Nevermind, just unnecessarily breaking nuts. Rockin' Doc May 22 2009 08:16 PM I'd go with whoever was the best defensively. It's not like their losing offense compared to Martinez. Martinez is not hitting (.063) and he has already committed 4 errors in roughly 25 innings. Edgy DC May 22 2009 08:30 PM My nuts have been busted to the consistency of baby powder already today. Edgy DC May 24 2009 09:45 PM Alexi Casilla, a prospect in the Luis Castillo mold who failed to replaced Luis when Castillo went to the Mets. Still young, played as much short as second in the minors, and is getting big league money to play down there now. Shot in the dark.

[Frayed Knot]

Jerry is quoted in today's NYPost at being slightly concerned with the "slow healing" of Reyes's calf strain.

[nymr83]

] Like have Church play SS

doesnt he throw lefty?

[Guest Edgy DC]

]Jerry is quoted in today's NYPost at being slightly concerned with the "slow healing" of Reyes's calf strain.

That does it. He's been dead for two days, and they're sitting on the story.

[RealityChuck]

="Ceetar":2rws4j9d]if this becomes an issue, they'll probably have some crazy fix. Like have Church play SS and put Murphy in right.[/quote:2rws4j9d]A left-handed throwing shortstop is not an idea whose time has come.

Ceetar May 18 2009 07:42 AM

="RealityChuck":2qolk1xx] ="Ceetar":2qolk1xx]if this becomes an issue, they'll probably have some crazy fix. Like have Church play SS and put Murphy in right.[/quote:2qolk1xx]A left-handed throwing shortstop is not an idea whose time has come.[/quote:2qolk1xx] That won't stop them. Besides, if you asked Keith, i'm sure he'd tell you that a "Right-handed first baseman is not an idea whose time has come." ;-) Actually, is that why Murphy and Reed are the two guys Manuel decided to mention about playing 1B? And..I've always wondered this, but why does Delgado play 1B righty? or why does he bad Lefty? which is it?! Edgy DC May 18 2009 08:22 AM ="Ceetar":32kkfa9d]Actually, is that why Murphy and Reed are the two guys Manuel decided to mention about playing 1B?[/quote:32kkfa9d] Since Murphy hasn't played yet, and Reed is behind Tatis, I'll guess not. DocTee May 18 2009 08:49 AM Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position! Nymr83 May 18 2009 09:35 AM ="DocTee":1a1olmaw]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:1a1olmaw] 15 years, 45 lbs, and a dozen injections ago maybe. Gwreck May 18 2009 10:29 AM ="DocTee":2fu35ilo]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:2fu35ilo] Hey, by that token, the solution is to put Delgado (once healthy) back at Catcher and use Tatis at first. No need to put Schneider, Castro or Santos in the lineup. LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr May 18 2009 11:47 AM ="Gwreck":35na9z32] ="DocTee":35na9z32]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:35na9z32] Hey, by that token, the solution is to put Delgado (once healthy) back at Catcher and use Tatis at first. No need to put Schneider, Castro or Santos in the lineup.[/quote:35na9z32] Marketing slogan: "Just like 1986... minus all that annoying pitching!" Benjamin Grimm May 18 2009 11:50 AM You know, we'd all like to see Bobby Valentine come back. (I'm included in that group.) But I think I'd almost rather see Davey Johnson come back. I think he'd be a good for this particular team. Not at all likely to happen, of course, but if I were in charge, I'd consider reaching out to him. LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr May 18 2009 11:58 AM ="soupcan":30mmzwu6]What did I miss? Why are we talking about replacement shortstops? Jose's injury more serious than first thought? I haven't read or seen that anywhere. Cora's finger broke or something? Edgy just worrying too much?[/quote:30mmzwu6] Cora already sprained his left thumb during the game Saturday sliding after a double... then did the same to his right thumb last night in the first on the EXACT SAME PLAY. Headfirst slides and dumbshit plays make the Creepy Sun Baby cry. Ashie62 May 18 2009 02:38 PM Can Murphy learn short if Reyes is going on hiatus? Are we getting the Jose on DL after 9 days routine Elster88 May 18 2009 10:48 PM Two errors and some awful turns at the plate for Ramon. Early returns indicate he is not a major league shortstop. smg58 May 19 2009 06:56 AM I hope Minaya has Jose Valentin's number on speed dial. Elster88 May 19 2009 10:00 PM How many at-bats until Ramon Martinez gets his first hit? I say 25 or being sent back down to AAA, whichever comes first. Edgy DC May 22 2009 08:08 PM OK, time to talk shortstops. Part of me thinks Putz was held out because he's being dangled as trade bait. Tejada at Bingo: .236 / .301 / .356 // .657 in 36 games. Coronado at Bingo: .316 / .409 / .474 // .883 in six games, but... Coronado at Buff: .141 / .240 / .165 // .404 in 29 games. Gun to my head, I go with Jose over Ruben, but... John Cougar Lunchbucket May 22 2009 08:14 PM Edited 2 time(s), most recently on May 22 2009 08:18 PM Nevermind, just unnecessarily breaking nuts. Rockin' Doc May 22 2009 08:16 PM I'd go with whoever was the best defensively. It's not like their losing offense compared to Martinez. Martinez is not hitting (.063) and he has already committed 4 errors in roughly 25 innings. Edgy DC May 22 2009 08:30 PM My nuts have been busted to the consistency of baby powder already today. Edgy DC May 24 2009 09:45 PM Alexi Casilla, a prospect in the Luis Castillo mold who failed to replaced Luis when Castillo went to the Mets. Still young, played as much short as second in the minors, and is getting big league money to play down there now. Shot in the dark.

[Ceetar]

="RealityChuck":2qolk1xx] ="Ceetar":2qolk1xx]if this becomes an issue, they'll probably have some crazy fix. Like have Church play SS and put Murphy in right.[/quote:2qolk1xx]A left-handed throwing shortstop is not an idea whose time has come.[/quote:2qolk1xx] That won't stop them. Besides, if you asked Keith, i'm sure he'd tell you that a "Right-handed first baseman is not an idea whose time has come." ;-) Actually, is that why Murphy and Reed are the two guys Manuel decided to mention about playing 1B? And..I've always wondered this, but why does Delgado play 1B righty? or why does he bad Lefty? which is it?! Edgy DC May 18 2009 08:22 AM ="Ceetar":32kkfa9d]Actually, is that why Murphy and Reed are the two guys Manuel decided to mention about playing 1B?[/quote:32kkfa9d] Since Murphy hasn't played yet, and Reed is behind Tatis, I'll guess not. DocTee May 18 2009 08:49 AM Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position! Nymr83 May 18 2009 09:35 AM ="DocTee":1a1olmaw]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:1a1olmaw] 15 years, 45 lbs, and a dozen injections ago maybe. Gwreck May 18 2009 10:29 AM ="DocTee":2fu35ilo]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:2fu35ilo] Hey, by that token, the solution is to put Delgado (once healthy) back at Catcher and use Tatis at first. No need to put Schneider, Castro or Santos in the lineup. LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr May 18 2009 11:47 AM ="Gwreck":35na9z32] ="DocTee":35na9z32]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:35na9z32] Hey, by that token, the solution is to put Delgado (once healthy) back at Catcher and use Tatis at first. No need to put Schneider, Castro or Santos in the lineup.[/quote:35na9z32] Marketing slogan: "Just like 1986... minus all that annoying pitching!" Benjamin Grimm May 18 2009 11:50 AM You know, we'd all like to see Bobby Valentine come back. (I'm included in that group.) But I think I'd almost rather see Davey Johnson come back. I think he'd be a good for this particular team. Not at all likely to happen, of course, but if I were in charge, I'd consider reaching out to him. LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr May 18 2009 11:58 AM ="soupcan":30mmzwu6]What did I miss? Why are we talking about replacement shortstops? Jose's injury more serious than first thought? I haven't read or seen that anywhere. Cora's finger broke or something? Edgy just worrying too much?[/quote:30mmzwu6] Cora already sprained his left thumb during the game Saturday sliding after a double... then did the same to his right thumb last night in the first on the EXACT SAME PLAY. Headfirst slides and dumbshit plays make the Creepy Sun Baby cry. Ashie62 May 18 2009 02:38 PM Can Murphy learn short if Reyes is going on hiatus? Are we getting the Jose on DL after 9 days routine Elster88 May 18 2009 10:48 PM Two errors and some awful turns at the plate for Ramon. Early returns indicate he is not a major league shortstop. smg58 May 19 2009 06:56 AM I hope Minaya has Jose Valentin's number on speed dial. Elster88 May 19 2009 10:00 PM How many at-bats until Ramon Martinez gets his first hit? I say 25 or being sent back down to AAA, whichever comes first. Edgy DC May 22 2009 08:08 PM OK, time to talk shortstops. Part of me thinks Putz was held out because he's being dangled as trade bait. Tejada at Bingo: .236 / .301 / .356 // .657 in 36 games. Coronado at Bingo: .316 / .409 / .474 // .883 in six games, but... Coronado at Buff: .141 / .240 / .165 // .404 in 29 games. Gun to my head, I go with Jose over Ruben, but... John Cougar Lunchbucket May 22 2009 08:14 PM Edited 2 time(s), most recently on May 22 2009 08:18 PM Nevermind, just unnecessarily breaking nuts. Rockin' Doc May 22 2009 08:16 PM I'd go with whoever was the best defensively. It's not like their losing offense compared to Martinez. Martinez is not hitting (.063) and he has already committed 4 errors in roughly 25 innings. Edgy DC May 22 2009 08:30 PM My nuts have been busted to the consistency of baby powder already today. Edgy DC May 24 2009 09:45 PM Alexi Casilla, a prospect in the Luis Castillo mold who failed to replaced Luis when Castillo went to the Mets. Still young, played as much short as second in the minors, and is getting big league money to play down there now. Shot in the dark.

[Guest Edgy DC]

="Ceetar":32kkfa9d]Actually, is that why Murphy and Reed are the two guys Manuel decided to mention about playing 1B?[/quote:32kkfa9d] Since Murphy hasn't played yet, and Reed is behind Tatis, I'll guess not.

DocTee May 18 2009 08:49 AM

Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position!

Nymr83 May 18 2009 09:35 AM

="DocTee":1a1olmaw]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:1a1olmaw] 15 years, 45 lbs, and a dozen injections ago maybe. Gwreck May 18 2009 10:29 AM ="DocTee":2fu35ilo]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:2fu35ilo] Hey, by that token, the solution is to put Delgado (once healthy) back at Catcher and use Tatis at first. No need to put Schneider, Castro or Santos in the lineup. LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr May 18 2009 11:47 AM ="Gwreck":35na9z32] ="DocTee":35na9z32]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:35na9z32] Hey, by that token, the solution is to put Delgado (once healthy) back at Catcher and use Tatis at first. No need to put Schneider, Castro or Santos in the lineup.[/quote:35na9z32] Marketing slogan: "Just like 1986... minus all that annoying pitching!" Benjamin Grimm May 18 2009 11:50 AM You know, we'd all like to see Bobby Valentine come back. (I'm included in that group.) But I think I'd almost rather see Davey Johnson come back. I think he'd be a good for this particular team. Not at all likely to happen, of course, but if I were in charge, I'd consider reaching out to him. LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr May 18 2009 11:58 AM ="soupcan":30mmzwu6]What did I miss? Why are we talking about replacement shortstops? Jose's injury more serious than first thought? I haven't read or seen that anywhere. Cora's finger broke or something? Edgy just worrying too much?[/quote:30mmzwu6] Cora already sprained his left thumb during the game Saturday sliding after a double... then did the same to his right thumb last night in the first on the EXACT SAME PLAY. Headfirst slides and dumbshit plays make the Creepy Sun Baby cry. Ashie62 May 18 2009 02:38 PM Can Murphy learn short if Reyes is going on hiatus? Are we getting the Jose on DL after 9 days routine Elster88 May 18 2009 10:48 PM Two errors and some awful turns at the plate for Ramon. Early returns indicate he is not a major league shortstop. smg58 May 19 2009 06:56 AM I hope Minaya has Jose Valentin's number on speed dial. Elster88 May 19 2009 10:00 PM How many at-bats until Ramon Martinez gets his first hit? I say 25 or being sent back down to AAA, whichever comes first. Edgy DC May 22 2009 08:08 PM OK, time to talk shortstops. Part of me thinks Putz was held out because he's being dangled as trade bait. Tejada at Bingo: .236 / .301 / .356 // .657 in 36 games. Coronado at Bingo: .316 / .409 / .474 // .883 in six games, but... Coronado at Buff: .141 / .240 / .165 // .404 in 29 games. Gun to my head, I go with Jose over Ruben, but... John Cougar Lunchbucket May 22 2009 08:14 PM Edited 2 time(s), most recently on May 22 2009 08:18 PM Nevermind, just unnecessarily breaking nuts. Rockin' Doc May 22 2009 08:16 PM I'd go with whoever was the best defensively. It's not like their losing offense compared to Martinez. Martinez is not hitting (.063) and he has already committed 4 errors in roughly 25 innings. Edgy DC May 22 2009 08:30 PM My nuts have been busted to the consistency of baby powder already today. Edgy DC May 24 2009 09:45 PM Alexi Casilla, a prospect in the Luis Castillo mold who failed to replaced Luis when Castillo went to the Mets. Still young, played as much short as second in the minors, and is getting big league money to play down there now. Shot in the dark.

[DocTee]

Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position!

[nymr83]

="DocTee":1a1olmaw]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:1a1olmaw] 15 years, 45 lbs, and a dozen injections ago maybe.

Gwreck May 18 2009 10:29 AM

="DocTee":2fu35ilo]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:2fu35ilo] Hey, by that token, the solution is to put Delgado (once healthy) back at Catcher and use Tatis at first. No need to put Schneider, Castro or Santos in the lineup. LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr May 18 2009 11:47 AM ="Gwreck":35na9z32] ="DocTee":35na9z32]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:35na9z32] Hey, by that token, the solution is to put Delgado (once healthy) back at Catcher and use Tatis at first. No need to put Schneider, Castro or Santos in the lineup.[/quote:35na9z32] Marketing slogan: "Just like 1986... minus all that annoying pitching!" Benjamin Grimm May 18 2009 11:50 AM You know, we'd all like to see Bobby Valentine come back. (I'm included in that group.) But I think I'd almost rather see Davey Johnson come back. I think he'd be a good for this particular team. Not at all likely to happen, of course, but if I were in charge, I'd consider reaching out to him. LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr May 18 2009 11:58 AM ="soupcan":30mmzwu6]What did I miss? Why are we talking about replacement shortstops? Jose's injury more serious than first thought? I haven't read or seen that anywhere. Cora's finger broke or something? Edgy just worrying too much?[/quote:30mmzwu6] Cora already sprained his left thumb during the game Saturday sliding after a double... then did the same to his right thumb last night in the first on the EXACT SAME PLAY. Headfirst slides and dumbshit plays make the Creepy Sun Baby cry. Ashie62 May 18 2009 02:38 PM Can Murphy learn short if Reyes is going on hiatus? Are we getting the Jose on DL after 9 days routine Elster88 May 18 2009 10:48 PM Two errors and some awful turns at the plate for Ramon. Early returns indicate he is not a major league shortstop. smg58 May 19 2009 06:56 AM I hope Minaya has Jose Valentin's number on speed dial. Elster88 May 19 2009 10:00 PM How many at-bats until Ramon Martinez gets his first hit? I say 25 or being sent back down to AAA, whichever comes first. Edgy DC May 22 2009 08:08 PM OK, time to talk shortstops. Part of me thinks Putz was held out because he's being dangled as trade bait. Tejada at Bingo: .236 / .301 / .356 // .657 in 36 games. Coronado at Bingo: .316 / .409 / .474 // .883 in six games, but... Coronado at Buff: .141 / .240 / .165 // .404 in 29 games. Gun to my head, I go with Jose over Ruben, but... John Cougar Lunchbucket May 22 2009 08:14 PM Edited 2 time(s), most recently on May 22 2009 08:18 PM Nevermind, just unnecessarily breaking nuts. Rockin' Doc May 22 2009 08:16 PM I'd go with whoever was the best defensively. It's not like their losing offense compared to Martinez. Martinez is not hitting (.063) and he has already committed 4 errors in roughly 25 innings. Edgy DC May 22 2009 08:30 PM My nuts have been busted to the consistency of baby powder already today. Edgy DC May 24 2009 09:45 PM Alexi Casilla, a prospect in the Luis Castillo mold who failed to replaced Luis when Castillo went to the Mets. Still young, played as much short as second in the minors, and is getting big league money to play down there now. Shot in the dark.

[Gwreck]

="DocTee":2fu35ilo]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:2fu35ilo] Hey, by that token, the solution is to put Delgado (once healthy) back at Catcher and use Tatis at first. No need to put Schneider, Castro or Santos in the lineup.

LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr May 18 2009 11:47 AM

="Gwreck":35na9z32] ="DocTee":35na9z32]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:35na9z32] Hey, by that token, the solution is to put Delgado (once healthy) back at Catcher and use Tatis at first. No need to put Schneider, Castro or Santos in the lineup.[/quote:35na9z32] Marketing slogan: "Just like 1986... minus all that annoying pitching!" Benjamin Grimm May 18 2009 11:50 AM You know, we'd all like to see Bobby Valentine come back. (I'm included in that group.) But I think I'd almost rather see Davey Johnson come back. I think he'd be a good for this particular team. Not at all likely to happen, of course, but if I were in charge, I'd consider reaching out to him. LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr May 18 2009 11:58 AM ="soupcan":30mmzwu6]What did I miss? Why are we talking about replacement shortstops? Jose's injury more serious than first thought? I haven't read or seen that anywhere. Cora's finger broke or something? Edgy just worrying too much?[/quote:30mmzwu6] Cora already sprained his left thumb during the game Saturday sliding after a double... then did the same to his right thumb last night in the first on the EXACT SAME PLAY. Headfirst slides and dumbshit plays make the Creepy Sun Baby cry. Ashie62 May 18 2009 02:38 PM Can Murphy learn short if Reyes is going on hiatus? Are we getting the Jose on DL after 9 days routine Elster88 May 18 2009 10:48 PM Two errors and some awful turns at the plate for Ramon. Early returns indicate he is not a major league shortstop. smg58 May 19 2009 06:56 AM I hope Minaya has Jose Valentin's number on speed dial. Elster88 May 19 2009 10:00 PM How many at-bats until Ramon Martinez gets his first hit? I say 25 or being sent back down to AAA, whichever comes first. Edgy DC May 22 2009 08:08 PM OK, time to talk shortstops. Part of me thinks Putz was held out because he's being dangled as trade bait. Tejada at Bingo: .236 / .301 / .356 // .657 in 36 games. Coronado at Bingo: .316 / .409 / .474 // .883 in six games, but... Coronado at Buff: .141 / .240 / .165 // .404 in 29 games. Gun to my head, I go with Jose over Ruben, but... John Cougar Lunchbucket May 22 2009 08:14 PM Edited 2 time(s), most recently on May 22 2009 08:18 PM Nevermind, just unnecessarily breaking nuts. Rockin' Doc May 22 2009 08:16 PM I'd go with whoever was the best defensively. It's not like their losing offense compared to Martinez. Martinez is not hitting (.063) and he has already committed 4 errors in roughly 25 innings. Edgy DC May 22 2009 08:30 PM My nuts have been busted to the consistency of baby powder already today. Edgy DC May 24 2009 09:45 PM Alexi Casilla, a prospect in the Luis Castillo mold who failed to replaced Luis when Castillo went to the Mets. Still young, played as much short as second in the minors, and is getting big league money to play down there now. Shot in the dark.

[Guest LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr]

="Gwreck":35na9z32] ="DocTee":35na9z32]Play Sheff at Short. It's his original position![/quote:35na9z32] Hey, by that token, the solution is to put Delgado (once healthy) back at Catcher and use Tatis at first. No need to put Schneider, Castro or Santos in the lineup.[/quote:35na9z32] Marketing slogan: "Just like 1986... minus all that annoying pitching!" Benjamin Grimm May 18 2009 11:50 AM You know, we'd all like to see Bobby Valentine come back. (I'm included in that group.) But I think I'd almost rather see Davey Johnson come back. I think he'd be a good for this particular team. Not at all likely to happen, of course, but if I were in charge, I'd consider reaching out to him. LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr May 18 2009 11:58 AM ="soupcan":30mmzwu6]What did I miss? Why are we talking about replacement shortstops? Jose's injury more serious than first thought? I haven't read or seen that anywhere. Cora's finger broke or something? Edgy just worrying too much?[/quote:30mmzwu6] Cora already sprained his left thumb during the game Saturday sliding after a double... then did the same to his right thumb last night in the first on the EXACT SAME PLAY. Headfirst slides and dumbshit plays make the Creepy Sun Baby cry. Ashie62 May 18 2009 02:38 PM Can Murphy learn short if Reyes is going on hiatus? Are we getting the Jose on DL after 9 days routine Elster88 May 18 2009 10:48 PM Two errors and some awful turns at the plate for Ramon. Early returns indicate he is not a major league shortstop. smg58 May 19 2009 06:56 AM I hope Minaya has Jose Valentin's number on speed dial. Elster88 May 19 2009 10:00 PM How many at-bats until Ramon Martinez gets his first hit? I say 25 or being sent back down to AAA, whichever comes first. Edgy DC May 22 2009 08:08 PM OK, time to talk shortstops. Part of me thinks Putz was held out because he's being dangled as trade bait. Tejada at Bingo: .236 / .301 / .356 // .657 in 36 games. Coronado at Bingo: .316 / .409 / .474 // .883 in six games, but... Coronado at Buff: .141 / .240 / .165 // .404 in 29 games. Gun to my head, I go with Jose over Ruben, but... John Cougar Lunchbucket May 22 2009 08:14 PM Edited 2 time(s), most recently on May 22 2009 08:18 PM Nevermind, just unnecessarily breaking nuts. Rockin' Doc May 22 2009 08:16 PM I'd go with whoever was the best defensively. It's not like their losing offense compared to Martinez. Martinez is not hitting (.063) and he has already committed 4 errors in roughly 25 innings. Edgy DC May 22 2009 08:30 PM My nuts have been busted to the consistency of baby powder already today. Edgy DC May 24 2009 09:45 PM Alexi Casilla, a prospect in the Luis Castillo mold who failed to replaced Luis when Castillo went to the Mets. Still young, played as much short as second in the minors, and is getting big league money to play down there now. Shot in the dark.

[Benjamin Grimm]

You know, we'd all like to see Bobby Valentine come back. (I'm included in that group.) But I think I'd almost rather see Davey Johnson come back. I think he'd be a good for this particular team.

Not at all likely to happen, of course, but if I were in charge, I'd consider reaching out to him.

[Guest LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr]

="soupcan":30mmzwu6]What did I miss? Why are we talking about replacement shortstops? Jose's injury more serious than first thought? I haven't read or seen that anywhere. Cora's finger broke or something? Edgy just worrying too much?[/quote:30mmzwu6] Cora already sprained his left thumb during the game Saturday sliding after a double... then did the same to his right thumb last night in the first on the EXACT SAME PLAY. Headfirst slides and dumbshit plays make the Creepy Sun Baby cry.

Ashie62 May 18 2009 02:38 PM

Can Murphy learn short if Reyes is going on hiatus? Are we getting the Jose on DL after 9 days routine

Elster88 May 18 2009 10:48 PM

Two errors and some awful turns at the plate for Ramon. Early returns indicate he is not a major league shortstop.

smg58 May 19 2009 06:56 AM

I hope Minaya has Jose Valentin's number on speed dial.

Elster88 May 19 2009 10:00 PM

How many at-bats until Ramon Martinez gets his first hit? I say 25 or being sent back down to AAA, whichever comes first.

Edgy DC May 22 2009 08:08 PM

OK, time to talk shortstops. Part of me thinks Putz was held out because he's being dangled as trade bait. Tejada at Bingo: .236 / .301 / .356 // .657 in 36 games. Coronado at Bingo: .316 / .409 / .474 // .883 in six games, but... Coronado at Buff: .141 / .240 / .165 // .404 in 29 games. Gun to my head, I go with Jose over Ruben, but...

John Cougar Lunchbucket May 22 2009 08:14 PM Edited 2 time(s), most recently on May 22 2009 08:18 PM

Nevermind, just unnecessarily breaking nuts.

Rockin' Doc May 22 2009 08:16 PM

I'd go with whoever was the best defensively. It's not like their losing offense compared to Martinez. Martinez is not hitting (.063) and he has already committed 4 errors in roughly 25 innings.

Edgy DC May 22 2009 08:30 PM

My nuts have been busted to the consistency of baby powder already today.

Edgy DC May 24 2009 09:45 PM

Alexi Casilla, a prospect in the Luis Castillo mold who failed to replaced Luis when Castillo went to the Mets. Still young, played as much short as second in the minors, and is getting big league money to play down there now. Shot in the dark.

[ashie62]

Can Murphy learn short if Reyes is going on hiatus?

Are we getting the Jose on DL after 9 days routine

[Elster88]

Two errors and some awful turns at the plate for Ramon. Early returns indicate he is not a major league shortstop.

[smg58]

I hope Minaya has Jose Valentin's number on speed dial.

[Elster88]

How many at-bats until Ramon Martinez gets his first hit? I say 25 or being sent back down to AAA, whichever comes first.

[Guest Edgy DC]

OK, time to talk shortstops.

Part of me thinks Putz was held out because he's being dangled as trade bait.

Tejada at Bingo: .236 / .301 / .356 // .657 in 36 games.

Coronado at Bingo: .316 / .409 / .474 // .883 in six games,

but...

Coronado at Buff: .141 / .240 / .165 // .404 in 29 games.

Gun to my head, I go with Jose over Ruben, but...

[Guest John Cougar Lunchbucket]

Nevermind, just unnecessarily breaking nuts.

[Guest Rockin' Doc]

I'd go with whoever was the best defensively. It's not like their losing offense compared to Martinez. Martinez is not hitting (.063) and he has already committed 4 errors in roughly 25 innings.

[Guest Edgy DC]

My nuts have been busted to the consistency of baby powder already today.

[Guest Edgy DC]

Alexi Casilla, a prospect in the Luis Castillo mold who failed to replaced Luis when Castillo went to the Mets. Still young, played as much short as second in the minors, and is getting big league money to play down there now.

Shot in the dark.