If CY were a Carpenter

[Frayed Knot]

StL's Chris Carpenter wins NL CY Award

(32 votes)

Capenter: 19 - 12 - 1
Willis: 11 - 18 - 3
Clemens: 2 - 2 - 24
Oswalt: 0 - 0 - 2
Cordero: 0 - 0 - 1
Pettite: 0 - 0 - 1

[Guest Edgy DC]

2005 National League voting results � Pitcher Club 1st 2nd 3rd Points Chris Carpenter Cardinals 19 12 1 132 Dontrelle Willis Marlins 11 18 3 112 Roger Clemens Astros 2 2 24 40 Roy Oswalt Astros - - 2 2 Chad Cordero Nationals - - 1 1 Andy Pettitte Astros - - 1 1

[nymr83]

so the writers didn't look away from the wins column? Clemens had a historically good season.

153, 151, 221, 141 are the ERA+ scores of the top 4, which do YOU think had the best year, this isn't even close.

btw, this was the 16th highest ERA+ of all time and i have a strong feeling those 2 votes came from Houston writers.....this man was ROBBED.

[Guest Edgy DC]

If you look at his win in 2001, it all comes out in the wash.

For him, at least.

[seawolf17]

How the hell did Ishii not even get a single third-place vote?!?! I'm stunned.

[Zvon]

A buddy from Houston just emailed me the other day about how Clemens was sure to win this award. And the Rocket had the numbers.
Only 2 votes! Im truly shocked.

Still, Ill have some fun with this when I respond to him,lol.

I wasnt surprized Carpenter got it.
I was suprised it wasnt closer between the top 3:
Carpenter,Willis and Clemens.

[Guest SI Metman]

I'm actually more shocked that Pedro didn't pick up a third place vote or two...

[Guest Edgy DC]

Should probably have more like ten slots on the ballot.

[Elster88]

Nymr83 wrote: so the writers didn't look away from the wins column? Clemens had a historically good season. 153, 151, 221, 141 are the ERA+ scores of the top 4, which do YOU think had the best year, this isn't even close. btw, this was the 16th highest ERA+ of all time and i have a strong feeling those 2 votes came from Houston writers.....this man was ROBBED.

FUCK CLEMENS.