Edgy DC wrote: But, as a showcase, doesn't it fail in it's purpose by not representing a baseball game at all? My position gets little support, so I'll throw it out there again. Give the players a full fucking week off. We'll get our vactions in without worrying about missing ball. We'll long for baseball to the point where there'll almost be a second opening-day atomosphere when the season re-starts. Wounded folks will heal.In return for selected players not getting the week off, put their families up in Grade-A accomdations. Treat 'em like gold.Play three All-Star games, with the tie-breaker on a weekend. Set them in them three nearby cities on alternating days --- i.e. Tuesday at Miller Field, Thursday at Wrigley, Saturday at Comerica. --- that way children don't grow old waiting for their team to host an All-Star game. Like I did.Play competitively, by leaving the starting pitchers in for five, and the starting players in for the full game unless stragegy demands otherwise. Three pitchers in each league usually deserve the start anyhow. Reserves get their chance to shine by getting starts thrown to them in Games Two and Three, not by endless and unscoreable substitutions that, rather than give everybody a chance to shine, more typically gives nobody a chance to shine --- and ruins the game to boot.Have the players play for a big pot o' money --- 75% to the winners, 25% to the losers. Have an equal pot go to the charitable institution choice of the players. I like all those suggestions. The tie breaker scenario is kool, but would only apply in years when the 1st two games are split. If they did ever go to three games, they'd never allow it to be a best of three, for fear of losing gate on that 3rd game. And I know you didnt pose it as a best of three series. Im just saying. I like the idea cuz for me the more baseball, the merrier I am. The week off also brings into discussion the possibliity of going back to a 154 game season. But Id much rather baseball went back to double headers--the kind where you got two games for the price of one. Some aspects of what has been done to the game today, like split double headers, really makes me puke. Like they dont make enough $$ already. (its not the fans fault they pay players so much money. Yet, they pay for it) And if I remember right, real double headers used to do just fine attendance wise, because everyone loves a deal like that. Especially families and kids. ( I remember walking from Lefrak City, thru Flushing Meadows, with my friends to Shea for double headers. We all had our gloves and would play catch as we went ) Maybe they feel people today dont have the attention span (they might even think this in terms of a single baseball game these days) to sit through two entire games. I think MLBs wrong in that regard, though Im a diehard baseball fan,...old schoolstyle. Maybe Im wrong.