soupcan wrote: Ceetar wrote: I don't see anyway that it suggests he didn't shove her into a glass door and injure her. And it's not like they're remotely equal in stature. He's a ripped professional athlete, it doesn't matter if it was blown out of proportion, he still intentionally attacked her. 'Suggests'? Yeah, you're probably right. But without charges being filed and having his wife's testimony, you don't really know what happened. You don't know what their relationship is like. There are quite a few unkowns here. Could be Jose didn't fight the MLB suspension to protect her. You don't know. Again - I don't want to come off as if I'm defending Jose. I'm just trying to sort of play devil's advocate here and point out just how much is unknown. a lot is unknown, but what's not unknown is that we have a 911 call and a medical report (well, we have the 911 call, _someone_ has a medical report) I mean, we can get into the shades of gray about how bad a domestic violence incident it was. People lose their temper and act in anger all the time, but in the end, when the result is an injured person it doesn't really matter why. I do think there is a road to some sort of 'redemption' for Jose, but between the diminished skills, and the positional adjustment, that road is just not the Mets. It doesn't really matter what they investigate about it. I'm not sure there's a single realistic phrase that could come from the Mets, owned by Jeff Wilpon, that would redeem the signing of Jose Reyes in the light of the violence.