Ceetar wrote: Vic Sage wrote: I agree with Sherman's premise; Pitching + Power = winning team. So i don't think the Mets can be too choosy about populating their OF, vis-a-vis the L/R issue. They need players, regardless of what side they hit from. Sure, ideally you want some balance in the lineup, but the budget being what it is, Sandy's not in an "ideal" situation. I don't think he should pass on Garrett Jones, or even Ibanez, solely based on handedness. The Giants would disagree. and Ibanez really sucks. It's possibly to overcompensate for sure, but with Murphy, Davis, and probably at least most of Duda, Nieuwenhuis, Thole (And throw in Baxter and Turner as well) you need some right-balanced desperately or you're gonna get chewed up by lefty pitchers. the giants would disagree about what? that pitching and power is a viable formula? I didn't say its the ONLY way, nor did Sherman. But its a perfectly viable one. And Ibanez sucks? Tell that to the Orioles. At age 40, he hit 20 HRs in 400 PAs. Can he field? no, but neither can Duda. look, i'm not saying we should sign a 40+ year old guy on his way out, but we're going to have to be creative and broadminded in filling out this team in a way that will make it competitive on a budget eaten up by a small handful of players. And not all LHs are eaten up by lefty pitchers, and not all RHs are great at hitting lefties either. And beggars can't be choosers. we're going to have flaws somewhere. I'd just as soon they find the best available OFers and not be concerned overmuch by what side of the plate they stand on.