smg58 wrote: I would argue that Nimmo needs to hit for more pop too, or pitchers won't allow him to draw that many walks. Lagares' glove is still a big asset, and if he improves any facet of his hitting he deserves to play every day. But we'll see. Everyone's an optimist this time of year (not that there's anything wrong with that). 1) You could certainly argue that about Nimmo, but you'd be totally wrong. There are many players in baseball that have produced good OB% without a lot of power. And besides, Nimmo has exhibited power in the minors, and has shown more power than Lagares in the majors, too. 2) If you're prognosticating about what pitchers will or won't do with Nimmo in the future, see (1) above. 3) Yes, a player's defense is a big asset... in an era of run scarcity, where any single run has greater impact (because there are fewer of them scored) and where the marginal number of runs saved that results from superior glove work (over average fielding) by 1 of the 9 defenders on the field is more likely to have an effect on a win-vs-loss. But in an era of run inflation, like we're in NOW, where everybody and their sister hits 20 hr/yr, caring an 82 OPS+ in CF because he catches the ball good is just foolish, IMO. Even if Lagares can get that OPS+ up to 95, that would be a huge improvement and still below average. And Nimmo, still young and developing, is more likely to improve on his 104 OPS+ than Lagares is at age 28, going on 29. 4) Lagares will deserve to play every day if he ever becomes a solid hitter (not just if he improves "any facet") --- and only if gets traded, because he won't be playing over Cespedes, Conforto and Bruce, unless there is an injury. 5) Anyone is entitled to optimism, but I like to base mine on some observable reality rather than just magical thinking. it's a fair question to wonder how much more a guy's defense has to contribute to offset an inferior bat. But that's an analysis that's era- and lineup-dependent. In this era, in this lineup, i'd rather have a Nimmo's ACTUALLY superior offense and average defense than Lagare's POTENTIALLY improved but still inferior (or even average) offense and superior defense.