First of all, damning a drama for not being funny is kind of missing the point. Yes, IN BRUGES was funny. This one isn't, and wasn't trying to be, despite some comic moments from Rockwell, Harrelson and McDormand. Secondly, i don't find a character's redemption to be too hard to believe. especially, when he's played by Sam Rockwell. It seemed clear to me, throughout the movie, that this not-to-bright momma's boy was desperate for Sheriff Woody's attention (as a surrogate father), and his violence and racism was a rather thin, alcohol-fueled veneer over his self-loathing and a real human desire to connect. When he suffers the multiple traumas the story provides (including the life-affirming, post-mortem letter from Woody) and then is literally purged by flame, his transformation feels earned and valid. As to characters not facing justice for their crimes... it's a small town in the south. The fact that crimes go unpunished doesn't shock my sensibilities or make me cry bullshit. It isn't a perfect movie, but McDonagh is one helluva good writer, its a great cast, and there are moments of great sadness, beauty and redemption in it.