The problem is in finding a way to make the cutoffs. As it stands, the examples listed in the opening post lump among the 'up-and-comers' players who are nearly at (or in some cases past) their FA years: Soriano, Molina, Aramis Ramirez, Andruw, Sheets, Nathan, Ryan, etc., with some who have barely made a dent so far; Fielder, Diaz, Felix Hernandez, Jacobs, and so on. Similar differences exist within the fade-out group too. As a result, that list doesn't represent a 1 year phenomenom but instead spans about a 5-6 year era.