Absent any steroid controversy, which 1st baseman gets more HOF votes; McGwire or Bagwell? -- I think the answer to that is unquestionably McGwire. Now, if I were to offer you a 1st sacker that would be guaranteed to have the exact same career as those two: same strengths, same weaknesses, same length of career, etc., who do you pick? -- To me, the answer to that one is Bagwell. He ran much better, fielded much better, better BA & OBP, more RBIs, maybe had lower peaks (although did get an MVP and more top-10s) but also a longer prime. Then I wonder how many of the voters would answer that question the same way, but yet not vote that way