We all know that the Mays/24 thing was the result of some kind of promise made to Willie from Joan Payson. Now with Payson long gone and her relatives no longer connected with the club, and with Willie not really having connections either nor much of a family to object (he just out-lived his 2nd wife) I wonder if they're waiting for him to die in order to feel that the promise was fulfilled and #24 is fair game again. By contrast, Carter, dying young as he did, probably makes them less likely to re-issue #8 as it would look like jumping on the grave if you were to do it at this point. I'd prefer they inform the family that, following a specified period (X years after his passing) they're going to put it back in circulation. Either way, this 'limbo' that those two numbers are in is the worst case scenario IMO. Either retire them officially or start using them again (and don't retire them officially).