]I guess, but I put Zambrano at seventh in our rotation anyway so do i, but unfortunately Willie may not be on the same wavelength. i'd be VERY upset to see Zambrano in our rotation the way things stand right now. the ERA+ over the last 3 years for our (main) current options: player 2005 2004 2003 Martinez 148 125 212 Glavine 118 119 94 Benson 101 97 85 Seo 162 87 111 Traschel 101 107 112 Heilman 132 78 63 Zambrano 100 101 108 It is clear that Pedro is and should be in. it is clear (i think) that Glavine is and should be in. after that its pretty difficult, but here's what i'd do and why: the 3rd spot would go to Jae Seo who clearly outpitched the others this past year. this leaves Heilman, Benson, Traschel, and Zambrano for 2 spots. I would leave Heilman in the bullpen. he might be better than these other guys, but he might not be, and his (i think) proven value in the bullpen makes him worth leaving there as long as there are roughly equivalent options available for the rotation. Traschel has been slightly better than the other 2 and, we believe, he would not be easily converted to relief pitching. i'd give him the 4th spot. that leaves us with zambrano and benson...and you know what? i might have spent the last year and a half bashing zambrano, but when you look at the numbers he has been a slightly better pitcher than kris benson (though both have spent their careers being essentially average.) the only thing to think about here is that since the two of them (and Traschel) are probably about equal, shouldn't you trade the one with the most value to other teams insteda of the one with the most objective value? in the end i'd start Martinez, Glavine, Seo, Traschel, and Benson with Heilman in the bullpen and trading Zambrano for some kind of help.