Mets Video
It seems that the New York Mets are still evaluating whether to bring back 38-year-old veteran Brooks Raley, and I have to admit that I don’t dislike the idea. The Raley and A.J. Minter duo was fantastic during much of the first half of the season, until the Mets’ aspirations faded and everything fell apart. Minter did not allow earned runs in his first 15 appearances, but Raley was not far behind, pitching to a 1.25 ERA and 3.05 FIP in his first 24 appearances, with 10 holds and 25 strikeouts in 21⅓ innings. Notably, he allowed just one home run against the first 92 batters he faced.
It was reassuring to see Minter doing Minter things and Raley doing Raley things, overcoming high-pressure situations and shutting down left-handed hitters above all. Two experienced left-handed relievers, with different styles, who offered that interesting contrast that worked for the Mets. Then, when Minter moved to Minnesota and Raley to Philadelphia at the trade deadline, the story took a complete turn for both pitchers, but Raley’s ending was much more puzzling, finishing with four blown saves in his final 37 appearances and 18 runs allowed in 31 innings, which pushed his ERA up to 4.65.
Behind the explosion in his FIP, which went from 3.10 to 7.07, was the fact that Raley became vulnerable to contact much more frequently. His opponents managed a .382 BABIP against him in Philly, the highest in any stretch of at least 15 relief appearances in his career. In addition, when hitters lifted the ball against him, they recorded a 28.6% HR/FB rate, an absurd jump above the 4.4% he allowed in his 45 appearances with the Mets. We know how much some bad outings can influence a reliever’s final tallies due to small sample sizes; for that reason, it's important to acknowledge that Raley’s problem goes beyond just the home runs allowed.
What I'm most concerned with is his seemingly fading ability to dominate lefties.
Let’s analyze this comparison, which includes the seasons in which Raley has faced at least 75 left-handed hitters. I added the 2025 results because, although Raley faced only 33 hitters, they serve as a reference for comparing his most recent dominance pace with that of this season.
As you can appreciate, there are major differences here in several key aspects:
1) Raley’s K-BB% rate against lefties from this year has been the worst of his entire career.
2) The more aggressive hitters were, they also managed to improve their contact considerably, especially against pitches outside the strike zone.
3) As a function of the first two points, lefty hitters ended up producing a 17.4% soft-contact rate, somewhat below Raley's career average of 21.7%.
As the free-agent market progresses, the Mets are likely to reserve their main resources until they know the outcome of their attempt to sign Tarik Skubal, who tops the team’s priorities and could receive a historic contract. Raley’s return would make sense if the Mets ultimately need to seek economical upgrades in the bullpen, although this huge question mark will remain even if he does return to New York.
If he can shut down lefties again, he'll closely resemble the Raley we saw in this season's first half. That kind of pitcher is worth bringing back no matter what.
Want to play the role of Mets general manager? Check out our free-to-use "You're The GM" offseason tool and build your own Mets roster!
Build Your 2027 Roster





Recommended Comments
There are no comments to display.
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now