Jump to content
Grand Central Mets
  • Create Account
  • Mets News & Analysis

    Two Left-Handed Starters Mets Should Target If They Can't Land Tarik Skubal

    If the price isn't right for Tarik Skubal, the Mets should pivot to these two free-agent southpaws.

    N.B. Lindberg
    Image courtesy of Gregory Fisher-USA TODAY Sports

    Mets Video

    The biggest prize of the offseason is, without a doubt, Tarik Skubal. He’s the best free-agent pitcher since Gerrit Cole in 2019 to hit the market, and he is better than Cole was. Reeling in Skubal is going to take a record-setting contract, and the New York Mets appear to be one of the finalists. 

    However, pursuing isn’t the same thing as landing him. The Mets might have all the money in the world, but they are coming off a disastrous season, and the uncertainty around the next collective bargaining agreement might give them pause about dropping over $400 million on one player (again). 

    Despite Skubal being far and away the best free agent in this cycle, that doesn’t mean the Mets will come up empty-handed if they miss out on him—and there’s nothing stopping them from adding more pitching even if they do. Should the Mets strike out on Skubal, or just want another arm, these are two lefties they should pursue. 

    Trevor Rogers

    From a results standpoint, Trevor Rogers has been a bit of a rollercoaster the past two seasons. Over 18 starts and 109.2 innings in 2025, he ran a minuscule 1.81 ERA, good for 3.3 fWAR and 5.2 bWAR. Tabbed as the Orioles' ace heading into 2026, he had anything but an ace-like season. Over 30 starts and 169.2 innings, he posted a 4.03 ERA, 2.2 bWAR, and 4.0 fWAR. However, you’ll notice that his fWAR, on a per-inning basis, was hardly off the pace in 2026 compared to 2025, and there’s a reason for that. 

    Fangraphs WAR uses Fielder Independent Pitching (FIP) as the basis for WAR, while Baseball Reference WAR uses runs allowed with team defense and a few other components baked in. Over the course of many seasons, a pitcher’s FIP and ERA (functionally runs allowed) will likely converge, but over a single season, the two can vary wildly. 

    Despite Bob Gibson-like results in 2025, Rogers only mustered a 2.82 FIP and, more importantly, a 3.64 xFIP, which assumes an average home run-to-flyball rate. Unsurprisingly, in 2026, his BABIP and HR/FB ratio normalized, and he ended the season with a FIP of 3.45 and xFIP of 3.92. Statcast’s xERA tells a similar story; his 2025 xERA was 3.40, and it only ticked up to 3.60 in 2026. 

    So, what does this all mean? Well, it means we should ignore his wild ERA swing over the past two seasons and believe what the totality of the past two seasons is actually telling us. Since 2025, Rogers has an ERA of 3.16, xERA of 3.52, FIP of 3.20, and xFIP of 3.81. That’s not an all-world ace, but if Rogers is your number two or three option, you’re sitting pretty.

    On top of that, there’s reason to believe he could find another gear. He has turned his biggest weakness early in his career—walking batters—into a strength, suppresses hard contact, has developed a reliable breaking pitch, and at one point was a high-level strikeout artist. His best seasons have come when his changeup is working, as it was in 2021 and 2025, but last season it was tattooed, despite generally better locations. This could be a pitch-mixing issue, bad luck, or something mechanical in his delivery giving it away, but Rogers has had exceptional results with his changeup in the past, and was still a good pitcher last season without it. 

    Entering his age-29 season, Rogers has time on his side, and if this is the pitcher he is, you’d be entirely comfortable starting him in a playoff game. However, unlike most of the starting pitchers in this free-agent class, his upside is more than just wishful thinking. After Skubal, Rogers offers the next best combination of ceiling and floor. That won’t come cheap, but the top of the rotation isn’t the place to get miserly. 

    Shota Imanaga

    After Rogers and Skubal, the free-agent starting pitcher market thins out considerably. It’s not that there aren’t plenty of solid options; rather, there are few, if any, with considerable upside. So, instead of gunning for an upside play, the Mets should pivot to a surer thing, namely Shota Imanaga. 

    Imanaga is the quintessential soft-tossing, control lefty. Last season, his fastball averaged 91.6 MPH and topped out at 93.8, but that hasn’t stopped him from racking up innings and getting outs. Over three seasons in MLB, he has a 3.45 ERA and 3.71 xERA, which solidifies his mid-rotation bona fides. 

    Likewise, the lack of velocity didn’t stop him from striking out a quarter of the batters he faced (24.6%) in 2026. He is a master of locating his fastball at the top of the zone, where it plays best, which leads to more whiffs than the velocity would suggest and plenty of infield pop-ups. And to finish off hitters, he’ll bait them with an excellent splitter or sweeper. 

    The only problem with Imanaga’s approach is that he gives up a ton of home runs. When your stuff isn’t lights out, and you pound the zone, the cost of doing business is significant damage on mistakes in the heart of the zone. However, while Imanaga will always be a bit homer-prone, there’s reason to believe he won’t have a repeat of last season’s 35 bombs allowed.

    As a left-handed pitcher, it should come as no surprise to learn that Imanaga has generally handled lefties quite well. However, last season, he was downright awful against them, and it’s not hard to find the culprit.

    Shota Imanaga vs Lefties

    Season

    Handedness

    K%

    BB%

    BABIP

    LOB%

    FIP

    HR/9

    2024

    vs L

    28.40%

    2.80%

    0.261

    80.80%

    3.08

    1.23

    2025

    vs L

    23.40%

    6.90%

    0.26

    72.70%

    3.62

    1.03

    2026

    vs L

    26.00%

    6.80%

    0.252

    71.40%

    5.06

    2.14

    Career

    vs L

    25.90%

    5.60%

    0.257

    74.30%

    4.02

    1.53

    The cause for this sudden spike in home runs is almost certainly tied to his sweeper/slider. Over his first two stateside seasons, his slider was fantastic. He allowed a grand total of zero home runs on the pitch, racked up both whiffs and weak contact, but in 2026, he was tagged for six long balls. Part of that sudden spike is down to him leaning on the pitch more, but the per-pitch results were mixed.

    The shape of his sweeper changed, getting slightly more velocity and movement, which is usually a good thing. However, the results backed up. The underlying whiff and contact data declined, and his breaking ball run value percentile went from the 90th percentile in 2025 to the 17th in 2026. However, I don’t think the pitch characteristics were necessarily to blame. 

    In 2025, when he made mistakes with his slider in the zone, he wasn’t punished. In 2026, he was. It’s possible his sequencing became too predictable, the shape too conventional, or 2025 was a blessed year for the pitch. What’s most likely is that we saw the best of the pitch in 2025, the worst in 2026, and 2027 will see it settle in as a fine offering. 

    Still, despite being one of the most homer-prone pitchers in baseball, Imanaga has a career 3.45 ERA and was at 3.77 this past season. Some of that is down to Pete Crow-Armstrong patrolling center and Dansby Swanson and Nico Hoerner manning the middle infield, but every team needs 170 innings of solid work. 

    There’s also nothing stopping the Mets from helping him regain some of his sweeper shape, which was downright deadly in 2025, or help him unlock a cutter to pair with his high-spin four-seamer and elite splitter. The lack of velocity makes a massive jump unlikely, but when a pitcher has control this good, just a bit of improvement in the stuff department goes a long way. 

    It wouldn’t surprise me if the Cubs and Imanaga already have a framework for another deal, but that doesn’t mean the Mets can’t tempt him away. He’ll only be entering his age-33 season, and his velocity hasn’t passed the Rubicon yet. If I were the Mets, I’d overpay him on a two-year deal with a second-year team option.


    Want to play the role of Mets general manager? Check out our free-to-use "You're The GM" offseason tool and build your own Mets roster!

    Build Your 2027 Roster

    Follow Grand Central Mets For New York Mets News & Analysis

    Recent Mets Articles

    Recent Mets Videos


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    There are no comments to display.



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...