Mets Video
Heading into the offseason, Nolan McClean and Christian Scott are the only two starters the New York Mets should feel confident calling upon every fifth day. Last season, to address the frailties in their starting rotation, they turned to the trade market and Freddy Peralta. The expectation was Peralta would solidify the top of the rotation, lead the Mets to the playoffs, and ultimately sign a long-term extension. The less said about how that went, the better.
The prize of the offseason remains Tarik Skubal, and even if the Mets do wrangle him, they’ll still be a guy short in the rotation. These are two righties who could slide into the middle of the starting five and provide the steady production they thought they were going to get from Peralta.
Casey Mize
What Mize will get in free agency is anyone’s guess because of the Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde act he pulled this past season. Prior to being dealt to the San Diego Padres at the trade deadline, Mize was dealing; over 16 starts and 86.2 innings, he had a 2.70 ERA, with the peripherals to match. He had arguably been the Tigers’ best pitcher, who also happened to employ Tarik Skubal at the time. Then, all of a sudden, he was flaming garbage. In ten starts for the Padres, he was lit up for a 7.40 ERA, as everything fell apart.
The question with a pitcher like Mize isn’t which half do you believe—it’s where the middle ground is between the two. For 86.2 innings, he ran a 24.9% K% and 5.6% BB%, and then for the next 44.2, he collapsed to a 12.0% K% and 9.1% BB%. While he had never run a strikeout rate over 24% over a full season, I think it’s safe to assume his true talent is closer to the bigger number than the smaller one.
When you look under the hood, the stark contrast between his Detroit and San Diego performance is jarring. His velocity dipped, his control became more scattershot, and he stopped missing bats in and out of the zone. He might not have necessarily deserved a 7.40 ERA, but he definitely earned it.
When a pitcher collapses as suddenly and violently as Mize did, digging into the data usually doesn’t help. Outside of a massive spike in BABIP or HR/FB, chances are, something physical or mechanical is throwing the whole operation off. And in Mize’s case, I think his mechanics got out of whack in San Diego.
Upon joining the Padres, Mize appears to have gotten slightly less drive from his backside. Essentially, he rode his drive leg for a split second less, which would sometimes also force him to quickly rotate his hips to catch his arm up. The unsurprising result was less velocity from less efficient leg drive.
The difference is minuscule, but his power transfer is significantly better in the first clip. The key to pitching is to use linear drive off the back leg to create the rotational energy needed to open the hips. Whether it was fatigue or a slight loss of mechanical feeling, Mize clearly lost a bit of oomph off his back leg. In the first clip, he hit 94 MPH in the sixth inning, and in the second, he was at 92 MPH in the first inning.
Fortunately, this is an eminently solvable problem, and there’s no reason to believe he can’t approximate his 2025 full season results when he ran a 3.87 ERA over 149 innings. It could be as simple as getting his mechanics back to normal, or a better-managed in-season strength and conditioning program.
Mize certainly isn’t a perfect pitcher. He relies heavily on his slider and splitter, has never thrown more than 150.1 innings in a season, and runs relatively modest groundball rates (albeit with high infield pop-up frequency). Despite being a former first overall pick, there probably isn’t an ace hiding in there, but he is certainly a serviceable mid-rotation starter who has looked like a number two for half a season.
The Mets shouldn’t view him as anything other than a back-end option, but his upside is worth shelling out a bit more than you normally would. He won’t turn 30 until May, and he was excellent for half of 2026. That’s worth $15 million with a team option at least.
Kevin Gausman
Gausman is no longer the borderline Cy Young candidate he was at his peak, but he still does two things extremely well. He’ll take the bump every fifth game, and he still gets guys out.
There are no sure things with pitcher health, but since 2016, no one has thrown more innings (1815.1) or made more starts (312) than Gausman. He has made at least 30 starts every season since 2021, and that streak could have extended to 2016 if it weren’t for the shortened 2020 season and a trip to the bullpen in 2019. If you need innings eaten, for the past decade, there has been no one better at clearing their plate than Gausman.
Chewing up frames is great, but to make it worth it, you need to get guys out, and Gausman is still quite good in this department. His 4.51 ERA last season undersells his effectiveness. He had a 3.58 xFIP, 3.74 FIP, and 4.02 xERA, which basically sums up the Gausman experience. He strikes guys out and limits walks, but his two-pitch mix of fastball and splitter will lead to loud contact, especially as he traverses an order for the third time.
Almost all pitchers experience some form of decline the more times they turn a lineup over, and Gausman is no different... except he sort of was. Last season, his strikeout and walk rates remained almost unchanged from the first to second time he faced a lineup, but his HR/9 spiked from 0.51 to 1.76. The same trend held true when he turned a lineup over for a third time, but that hasn’t been the case throughout his career. Generally, his HR/9 and BB% would hold steady, while his K% would slowly decline the more familiar hitters got with him.
Heading into 2027, I think we should expect Gausman to continue to be the pitcher he has always been, just with a bit better home run luck. His 12.7% HR/FB ratio was his highest since 2020, which was the season prior to his breakout. Even if he continues to struggle with the long ball a bit, getting 175 innings of 4.00 ERA ball is incredibly valuable over a long season, and it won’t require a massive long-term deal to secure.
Want to play the role of Mets general manager? Check out our free-to-use "You're The GM" offseason tool and build your own Mets roster!
Build Your 2027 Roster




Recommended Comments
There are no comments to display.
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now