Yirsandy Rodríguez Grand Central Contributor Posted Tuesday at 11:51 AM Posted Tuesday at 11:51 AM The New York Mets are, reportedly, among the teams interested in Alec Bohm. When I read the news, the first thing I thought about was not the great urgency the Mets have at first base, but how many real differences exist between the most recent versions of Mark Vientos and Bohm, since it is clear that neither of them went through a good season in 2026. Although Bohm bounced back a little this year, in these last two seasons he has been far from the hitter who finished with 97 RBIs in two consecutive seasons during 2023 and 2024. Vientos, for his part, just finished the worst season of his career, with a negative-1.1 fWAR and the lowest production in home runs, RBIs, batting average, on-base percentage, slugging and BABIP. However, and you have probably noticed where I am going with this, when we compare Vientos and Bohm over the span of these last few seasons, some things they have in common stand out, and the only thing that has been different is that both began their respective careers as third basemen and have had to move to first base early because of their major defensive problems. I think there is no discussion that Vientos’ power is more outstanding, but he also strikes out more—I will not talk about how terrible both of them are as baserunners—which gives Bohm the advantage because of his greater contact ability, although both are highly aggressive hitters who have a lot of trouble walking. On defense, Bohm has been the worst third baseman of his generation if we go by DRS, but, taking OAA into account, the difference is close again and Vientos loses a little ground as a first baseman. I think it is quite clear that both are very similar players and, given that Bohm has a cleaner track record health-wise and has more experience, he seems like a better version of Vientos. Let it be clear that I am not taking credit away from Bohm, who took on much more prominent roles than Vientos with the Phillies in recent years. However, there is no way I can see this as a real opportunity for improvement for the team. This is not a free agency class with great first basemen, but there are better options out there. Ty France, for instance, is still available. Plus, even if the Mets were to reach an agreement, we would have to see how Bohm would take to a semi-platoon role, since Jared Young should also be part of the conversation. The incumbent plays better defense at first base, with +2 DRS in 641⅔ innings there this year, in addition to his consistent performance against right-handed pitchers (120 wRC+). Although there is no way a possible acquisition of Bohm would inspire a great deal of confidence in the organization's plans, at least he should work against left-handed pitchers, whom he hit well last year, producing an .816 OPS with a 120 wRC+, by far a better performance than his marked drop to a .643 OPS and 77 wRC+ against right-handers. At least those latter marks were better than Vientos, who was once again terrible against right-handers, with a .538 OPS and 48 wRC+. But if that's the only bar we're trying to clear, the Mets aren't going to be much better in 2027. Image courtesy of John Jones-Imagn Images View full article
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now