Frayed Knot wrote: Gwreck wrote: I don't think TV commentary works that way. Yeah, Keith would be way out of bounds if he simply took it upon himself to start offering advice to Lagares, or to anyone for that matter. He did say something about making a point of talking to Hudgens about what the philosophy/mind-set is in that type of AB He's stated in the past that he's talked to guys about certain things, hitting wise. I specifically remember an instance with Pagan where Keith was pointing out something which flying out from the shoulder and that Pagan is aware because he was talking to him about it. That's probably slightly different than pitch selection, but not by much. The thing is, a lot of it's just guessing. And if you're guessing at pitches, sometimes you're going to be wrong. And Keith, often times, is still using the scouting report from his playing days at times. "2-1 count, runners on, he's gonna throw.._this_" and when he's right and the batter disagrees, well.. But Keith and Ron get that guessing game right a lot, ancedotally.