G-Fafif wrote: Times picked up on the quote, though not with the investigative zeal (or Zeile) shown here. If we accept Randy is an adjective/nom-de-plume, then we must turn to Dunham's other clue, Mets of Jewish faith, heritage or at least partial identity. Since 1962, that group encompasses Joe Ginsberg, Norm Sherry, Greg Goossen, Art Shamsky, Elliott Maddox, Dave Roberts, Shawn Green, David Newhan, Scott Schoeneweis, Ike Davis, Josh Satin. Ginsberg, Goossen and Roberts are no longer with us (meaning if one of those was the guy, the author needs a new gyno). Nothing in the bio of the 83-year-old Sherry suggests he took up medicine. Have seen and heard enough of and from Shamsky and Maddox post-baseball to discern they didn't become doctors. Nobody else -- even from the perspective of young Lena -- would qualify as "an older Jewish man". Guessing, as suggested upthread, that if the whole thing isn't a clever fictionalization (or fabrication), the doctor might have said something to her once about going to a tryout camp or being drafted in the 43rd round and that became "my gynecologist played for the Mets." If by chance it's Schoeneweis, then Ms. Dunham should check her insurance to make sure it covers catastrophic events. And if it's Davis or Satin, perhaps she buys really lame pick-up lines in bars?