I try to balance out the people who give points to everyone. However, in this case you're probably right -- I probably oversimplified too much, even by my standards. I stand by my 5 points to Oliver, however.
The epitome of the good-field, no-hit shortstop -- Earl Weaver believed that a shortstop who prevented runs was more important than one who drove them in. Was taller than the average middle infielder -- like Marty Marion. Red Schoendienst. On edit...whoops...I'm way short of ten. I missed that rule. Anyone else wants to take Belanger, go to it.