This is a tough one. I love anything with Cusack (either Cusack). But I went with Stand By Me, maybe because I just watched it with my grandson -- but i think I would have picked it anyway.
From the Times: ]There are some great secrets of New York in autumn. ... Behind Grant�s Tomb is a beautiful art project of mosaic benches; in Central Park find Alice in Wonderland (especially at night with someone you love). And Brooklyn has a small pizza place that will not leave your mind called Di Fara�s pizza and the Brooklyn Bridge at sunrise or sunset.