Saying HoF status, 'or something close to it', is merely meant to say that I want an elite level player rather than merely a good one before deciding that no one else can ever soil that uniform #. I'd have less problem with Keith or Beltran, even though less than HoF, had they also not been short of 45% of PAs as a Met (Keith) or 35% (Carlos) and won their MVPs and performed WS heroics elsewhere, while Carter's actual HoF inclusion isn't enough to make up for his barely 25% of time as a Met. These are guidelines, not absolutes. But it also means that longtime Mets -- Kooz, Grote, Mookie, Krane, Reyes, etc. -- sometimes touted here and elsewhere wouldn't be on my list either because of their lack of elite status..