I meant that the defense in relation to Luis Castillo's was game-changing... the upgrade, IOW. I miswrote. (I was going to let it go because it's minor, but if you'd like to split hairs: are you really bringing up his hitting into a triple play once as representative of his skill with... I don't know, anything?) Tejada has more power than Castillo NOW and he's got a 17-year-old's frame at age 20; he's also put up a .330 (and climbing) OBP compared to "OBP specialist" Castillo's .347*. He's put up the same amount of WAR and more Fielding Runs (both cumulative stats) in a fraction of the time on the field. I realize you're more or less playing devil's advocate here. Still... you're wrong. Parse my language all you'd like, but make no mistake-- he has been an upgrade. But "half-decent" represents a significant upgrade over "useless;" a lamed Castillo having a down year is useless, while Tejada's been half-decent (and as long as he keeps up a modest level of production offensively, he'll continue to be so). If you disagree about that... man, we're watching different games. Yes I'm partially playing devil's advocate here, and of course Tejada is an upgrade over an injured Castillo, and of course at 20 y/o he's got the better future ahead of him. But just like CF's post earlier about how we shouldn't get too giddy and talk about Ike = Olerud yet, and like the premature cries from earlier seasons about how Argenis Reyes was the future, I just think that anyone not named Castillo is too quickly given credit for everything up to and including the sunrise based on the name alone. I don't believe the Met record would be even one game different had Castillo not gotten hurt and Tejada were still in Buffalo; I think the trade in offense is probably a wash at best (and not as good as Castillo v.2009) and the defensive upgrade is being exaggerated - turning DPs is one area I think both Castillo and Cora do quite well. My only point in bringing up the several errors (including dropping a peg from RF for a sure out) and the triple play is to imagine the reaction if Luis had done either much less both.