Michael Baumann, writing for Grantland, thinks the slide was dirty (plus a great football quote): Well, in a just world, we�d be talking about Jacob deGrom�s comprehensive dominance or Noah Syndergaard redrawing the boundaries of what we can expect in terms of velocity from a starting pitcher. We�d be talking about Zack Greinke being the best no. 2 starter in baseball, or how watching Bartolo Colon jog in from the bullpen in all his moonlike glory is a sight to warm the hearts of nations. But because baseball is a sport for people who like to suffer, we�re instead going to talk about Chase Utley�s takeout slide in Game 2. It was one of the most brutal and unnecessary acts of violence I�ve ever seen during the run of play in a baseball game. He came in late, off the base, and straight into Ruben Tejada�s extended plant leg, breaking his fibula. The slide was so vicious that it divided the ranks of former pro ballplayers, a group of people who apparently unanimously support choking out one�s coworker on television. If a play is borderline for them, it�s beyond the pale for normal people. This isn�t football, which is a shame, because in football, they give you a 15-yard penalty for clipping or roughing the whoever instead of giving you second base. Utley has been suspended for two games, and public opinion is divided between people who support the suspension or want harsher discipline and people who think either (1) that MLB moved the goalposts by deciding all at once to punish hard takeout slides after not having done so for 150 years, or (2) that suspending Utley is an attempt to quiet public criticism rather than to make the game safer. While I�m in favor of suspending Utley, who is appealing the ruling, I�m also sympathetic to the counterarguments. Certainly we don�t want arbitrary post hoc justice, such as it is in matters of on-field rule-breaking. And, further, we�d prefer the league to protect players out of a sense of right and wrong rather than the desire to avoid criticism. To the second point, I�d say that if someone does the right thing, I don�t really care what his motives are. Neither is it a bad thing that MLB is responding immediately to criticism that its game is not as safe as it could be � certainly being responsive to such things is good. And it looks like after this and a rash of other recent incidents, dating back to Jung-Ho Kang�s season-ending injury last month, that MLB will not only suspend Utley but change the rules governing slides. To the first point, that suspending Utley goes against rules and/or precedent, I guess my response is that I don�t really give a shit? If rules and precedent are the last fallback of people who defend such an obviously violent and un-baseball-like action, then maybe we ought to rethink the rules and precedent now, instead of waiting for the next broken leg. Established institutions are not intrinsically good � they are only as good or bad as the ends they service. http://grantland.com/the-triangle/2015-mlb-playoffs-dodgers-mets-cubs-cardinals-blue-jays-rangers-astros-royals-chase-utley/