Edgy MD wrote: Your point is not lost on me, but his elite defense has contributed beaucoup points to his value. That made me curious, so I looked up the DWar for each of them: PCA +1.2 Alonso - .6 Ohtani -.6 The first two seem reasonable. Yes, PCA is a good defender and we've seen Pete play good (at times excellent) defense this year, and for some reason, first basemen start out with a negative defensive score, BUT How does Ohtani even have a defensive score when he hasn't played one inning in the field this year? Doesn't make sense. Later