I don't have the records in front of me, but IIRC, Thomas started his career with 7 or 8 consecutive years of .300BA, 20+ HR, 100 R and 100 RBI. (or something like that - maybe 100BB, too. I may be off by a stat or two.) He was the only major leaguer other than Gehrig to do that. Those are the kinds of counting stats that many of the writer still use to judge players. But he went into a decline quickly because of health. After that, he tried to play hurt (no pun intended), but his numbers never reached his early ones. And he could no longer play the field. Even when healthy, he was only a 2 tool player. (Hit, hit for power) That keeps him from the HOF in my mind, by a narrow margin. Biggio, on the other hand, played three different positions -key defensive up the middle ones - second base, catcher and center field. And he played them all well. Plus, he's a gritty type pf player who is four away from the record for career HBP. I would vote for him. Later