I think Catfish Hunter opened the door for Jim Bunning. The case for Catfish was 224 wins and a Cy Young Award. And that's not that much, but it's Catfish. And then somebody says, well, hey, Bunning won exactly the same amount of games, and had a perfect game, cool nickname or not. Hunter went in in 1987, but Bunning had to wait until 1996. Bunning and Kooz were pretty darn close statistically but Bunning had the sorts of things on his CV that stood out: a hundred wins in each league, the perfect game, the post-career profile. It never occurred to me I was watching a Hall of Famer in Jerry Koosman, but it never occurred to me that Bunning was one, either. (I only caught him toward the end of his career, so maybe I missed his aura, but I really don't remember him being spoken of in reverential terms.) Bunning got in, Koosman was never seriously considered. Catfish was indeed Catfish. I'm always surprised by retroactive circumspection that he wasn't an automatic. Seaver, Palmer, Hunter for the bulk of the 1970s were strung together as the best in the game. Those impressions don't go away easily.