New York Mets Arbitration Decisions & Projections: Brett Baty

Image courtesy of Wendell Cruz-Imagn Images

Mets Video

The New York Mets selected Brett Baty with the 12th overall pick in the first round of the 2019 MLB Draft out of Lake Travis High School in Austin Texas. Baty quickly became a crown jewel in the farm system due to his prototypical size and raw power from the left side of the plate. He made a memorable major-league debut on August 17th, 2022 where he homered in his first career at-bat against the Atlanta Braves. He then appeared to solidify himself as the franchise's third baseman of the future in 2025 when he posted a career-high 3.1 bWAR and launched 18 home runs.

However, David Stearns' aggressive restructuring of the infield reshaped Baty's role heading into the 2026 season. With star infielder Bo Bichette locking down everyday duties at third base, Baty was forced into a new multi-positional role. He stayed on the active roster due to his athletic flexibility, playing six different positions including first base, second base and the corner outfield positions.

While his defensive versatility provided the Mets with a highly critical insurance policy, the lack of an everyday position noticeably disrupted his rhythm at the plate in 2026. Over 143 games and 420 at-bats, Baty posted a slash line of .236/.309/.371 with 11 home runs and 56 RBIs. A huge strikeout problem (26.4% strikeout rate) paved the way for a meager fWAR output of 1.1 Now entering salary arbitration for the first time in his career, Baty represents a complex player for a front office that must decide whether his versatile profile is a match for a roster in need of an overhaul.

Brett Baty's 2027 Arbitration Case In A Nutshell

2023 Salary: $720,000
2024 Salary: $750,000
2025 Salary: $774,000
2026 Salary: $811,500

2026 Stats: 143 G, 473 PA, .236/.309/.371 (.681 OPS), 11 HR, 22 2B, 1 3B, 56 RBI, 9.3% BB%, 26.4 K%

Mets Infield Depth:
Bo Bichette: 40-man roster
Christopher Morel: 40-man roster
Ronny Mauricio: 40-man roster
Mark Vientos: 40-man roster
Jorge Polanco: 40-man roster
Minor Leagues: Christian Cairo, Jefferson Rojas, Emilien Pitre

The Mets' infield depth chart is crowded with talent, but Baty's unique ability to play multiple positions gives him an advantage over one-dimensional alternative players. His primary internal competition comes from Christopher Morel and Ronny Mauricio. Morel offers excellent pop and Mauricio provides switch-hitting depth, but neither possesses the defensive flexibility that Baty demonstrated in the 2026 season. The front office also added depth by claiming Christian Cairo off waivers late in the 2026 season.

Mark Vientos is another internal threat, but because of his defensive struggles in 2026, he is likely anchored into a crowded designated hitter picture going forward. Looking down the pipeline, prospects like Emilien Pitre and Jefferson Rojas are knocking on the door in Triple-A, but neither is positioned to make an immediate disruption to the Mets' bench. Since the rest of the depth is limited, Baty serves as the ultimate utility player on the 26-man roster. He can become a key piece once again by plugging holes on the roster almost anywhere on the diamond.

Why the Mets Should Keep Brett Baty

Tendering a contract to Brett Baty should be a priority for David Stearns and the Mets front office. Entering his first year of arbitration eligibility, Baty is projected to have a highly affordable salary of about $2.5 million. For a team that values roster optimization and cos- controlled flexibility, paying a baseline rate for a former first-round pick who is entering his physical prime is an easy financial commitment.

Though his numbers floundered this year, Baty's quality of contact remained steady. According to Baseball Savant, he maintained a 10.3% barrel rate and a 42.0% hard-hit rate, both above-average figures. His average exit velocity tracked at 90.4 mph, which landed him in the 73rd percentile among all qualified hitters.

Defensively, advanced metrics highlight how crucial Baty was to keeping an injured squad afloat; he posted +1 Out Above Average (OAA) across all six positions he played, effectively giving the team a league-average glove at every position besides center field and catcher.

Letting a team-controlled player with strong defensive skills and a solid hard-hit rate walk over a modest $2.5 million contract would be an error by an organization that is looking to maintain a sustained championship window.

Why the Mets Could Non-Tender Brett Baty

Even with his affordable projected arbitration salary, the Mets' front office may still decide to non-tender Baty based on certain metrics.

While he can hit the ball with high-end exit velocity, he's struggled lifting the ball in the air consistently and through his time in the big leagues so far (he's posted a ground ball rate around 48% for his career). That inability to elevate the baseball—alongside his longstanding strikeout issues—has resulted in posting below-average slugging percentage and OPS numbers.

With the Mets' crowded infield and the team always being active in pursuing premium talent, they could non-tender Baty to free up both payroll flexibility and a 40-man roster spot rather than guaranteeing around $2 million to a utility player who you could argue has already plateaued. It'd be a short-sighted decision to be sure (see above), but you can't really count anything out from this front office.

Prediction

Expect this to be a straightforward decision by David Stearns and the Mets' front office. The organization will likely tender a contract to Brett Baty for the 2027 season, with both sides settling somewhere around the $2.5 million range. Baty will enter spring training without a guaranteed starting job at a single position, but his status as a left-handed super-utility weapon makes him a safe bet to anchor the Mets' bench next season.