New York Mets Arbitration Decisions & Projections: Francisco Alvarez

Image courtesy of Raymond Carlin III-Imagn Images

Mets Video

Francisco Alvarez signed with the New York Mets as a highly touted international free agent in 2018 and quickly worked his way through the farm system as a top prospect. During his first full season in 2023, Alvarez blasted 25 home runs across 123 games, solidifying his reputation as a power-hitting catcher and a vital spark plug for the franchise.

His path over the last three seasons has been a story of volatility, heavily disrupted by injuries. In 2024, a severe left thumb forced him onto the IL for nearly two months. While he returned to hit .237 with 11 home runs and caught every game of the Mets' postseason run, he struggled to maintain consistency at the plate. A fractured hamate bone delayed his start in 2025, but he rebounded to post a career-high .787 OPS and a +122 OPS+ in 76 games.

Alvarez stayed relatively healthy in 2026 as he logged 113 games, but his offensive output slipped back into an inconsistent pattern. He slashed .233/.311/.399 (.710 OPS) with 16 home runs and was right around league average with a 99 OPS+. While his raw power remains a threat, he also struck out at an alarming rate this season (30.7%).

Because Alvarez qualified early for arbitration as a Super Two player prior to the 2026 season, he is already entering his second arbitration cycle at just 24 years old. Having played on a $2.4 million figure this past year, David Stearns and the front office now face a familiar evaluation, do they view Alvarez as a developing core piece, or has inconsistency opened a door to a more platoon-heavy future strategy?

Francisco Alvarez's 2027 Arbitration Case

2023 Salary: $720,000
2024 Salary: $762,500
2025 Salary: $795,000
2026 Salary: $2,400,000

2026 Stats: 113 G, 420 PA, .233/.311/.399 (.710 OPS), 16 HR, 14 2B, 0 3B, 43 RBI, 9.3 BB%, 30.7 K%

Mets' depth at Catcher
Luis Torrens: 40-man roster
Hayden Senger: 40-man roster
Minor Leagues: Kevin Parada, Chris Suero

The primary internal factor complicating Alvarez's workload behind the plate is veteran backup catcher Luis Torrens, who remains secured on the roster. Rather than a late-inning or once-a-week defensive replacement, Torrens has become a legitimate alternative for manager Andy Green. Torrens hit nine home runs and drove in 41 runs over 91 games in 2026, posting a final slash line of .235/.295/.396.

The Mets also have dependable upper-minor league depth with defensive specialist Hayden Senger providing a high-floor insurance policy. Also down the pipeline is former first-round pick Kevin Parada, though Chris Suero is the more notable prospect at this point in time.

Furthermore, the ability to utilize Alvarez as a designated hitter is restricted considering the plethora of DH types on the Mets' roster. Alvarez's path to daily at-bats is tied to performance behind the dish, though his arbitration projection of $4-4.2 million is easy enough

Why Francisco Alvarez Should Stay With Mets

There's no circumstance in which he's going to be non-tendered, but Alvarez is a popular trade candidate for a reason. The foundational argument for retaining Alvarez rests on his rare combination of youth and power upside at a position where offensive production is notoriously scarce. Even in a down year in 2026, his underlying data remains solid. He registered an impressive 11.2% barrel rate and a 43.1% hard-hit rate while maintaining a slightly above average Isolated Power (ISO) of .166.

Historically, catchers develop at a slower rate due to the physical toll and cognitive demand that game-calling requires. Oftentimes, a catcher's true offensive peak won't materialize until they are in their late twenties. Even though his 99 wRC+ and .313 wOBA don't look great on the surface, they are better than what league-average backstops produced in 2026.

Trading or cutting bait on a catcher with this type of power floor and offensive potential is an unnecessary risk. At a projected salary raise that is easily affordable for the team's payroll, tendering him a contract ensures the Mets keep a high-ceiling, premium asset under team control during his prime years.

That being said, there are serious flaws in his game that need to be addressed. The primary concern is his regression in plate discipline metrics, which oftentimes stalled rallies due to a highly problematic 34.2% chase rate and an elevated 15.8% SwStr% (swinging strike percentage). He's also still not the best defensive catcher, despite the progress he made this year. The ABS challenge system was especially problematic for Alvarez, where he was only successful in 47% of his challenges.

Given all of that, perhaps it's no surprise Alvarez finished the 2026 season with an fWAR of 1.4, which was lower than Luis Torrens' fWAR of 2.1.

Prediction

Expect the Mets to tender Francisco Alvarez a contract for the 2027 season around the $4 million range. Despite his statistical steps backwards this year, his combination of age, position, and power ceiling make him an asset the Mets won't want to let go.