Jump to content
Grand Central Mets
  • Create Account
  • Mets News & Analysis

    Predicting Mets' Potential Rule 5 Draft Losses After Leaving Numerous Prospects Unprotected

    If there is a Rule 5 draft this year, the Mets might be one of the more interesting teams to watch, because they could lose some notable prospects.

    Tom Gatto
    Image courtesy of Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

    Mets Video

    David Stearns made either a big gamble or a big statement about the upper levels of the New York Mets’ minor-league system this week. He added only one prospect, infielder Jefferson Rojas, to the 40-man roster before Tuesday’s deadline to protect players from next month’s scheduled Rule 5 Draft. Rojas is the Mets’ No. 1 prospect on most publications’ lists after coming over from the Chicago Cubs at the trade deadline on Aug. 3, so he was an obvious call.

    But a handful of prospects who were highly regarded just last year were left off. Most notably, Stearns declined to protect Ryan Clifford, Jacob Reimer, Chris Suero, Randy Guzman and Jack Wenninger. Among players he acquired at the deadline this year, Gary Gill Hill and Zach Franklin also were exposed to the draft.

    That leaves us with questions:

    1. Is Stearns betting on the Rule 5 being canceled because of the impending lockout, as it was during the 2021-22 lockout? He might not be the only executive thinking that way, if the internet chatter is accurate.

    2. Is he betting that if there is a draft, history will repeat and teams will only draft pitchers and utility types? That there won’t be a Ryan Noda moment in 2026?

    In the past five Rule 5 drafts (2020, 2022-25), 71 players have been selected in the major-league phase, and 59 have been pitchers. Noda was one of the 12 position players. The then-Oakland Athletics selected the first baseman/DH in 2022, when he was 26.

    YEAR NO. P H METS LOST HITTERS DRAFTED
    2025 13 12 1 None Daniel Susac
    2024 15 11 4 Nate Lavender, Mike Vasil Liam Hicks, Cooper Bowman, Gage Workman, Christian Cairo
    2023 10 8 2 None Nasim Nunez, Deyvison De Los Santos
    2022 15 13 2 None Ryan Noda, Blake Sabol
    2020 18 15 3 Dedniel Nunez Akil Baddoo, Kyle Holder, Ka’ai Tom
    TOT 71 59 12    

    3. Has he soured on players he inherited three years ago? Did Clifford’s bad year at Triple-A, Reimer’s injury-shortened season at Double-A or Guzman’s injuries at Single-A convince him they can’t be a part of the future? If no, then see 1.

    4. Is he only willing to risk Rojas losing developmental time if the lockout goes past Opening Day? Or does he believe Rojas can make the club at second base/utility out of spring training? Players on the 40-man can’t play anywhere during a stoppage.

    5. Is he rolling the dice with his unprotected pitchers because he knows that it’s likely he’ll get them back at some point? As shown above, the Mets have lost three players, all pitchers over the past five Rule 5s. Nunez and Lavender returned, and both were effective out of the bullpen last season.

    None of these questions can be answered without asking Stearns directly, and good luck getting him to answer directly if they do get asked.

    But the bottom line is Stearns declined to shake up the 40-man roster when he had prospects to protect and players who could easily be cut to make room for them. Instead, he stayed with the likes of Christopher Morel, Hayden Senger, Jack Anderson and Pierson Ohl. (Dylan Ross was designated for assignment to make room for Rojas on the 40-man.) His reasons will remain hidden until at least labor peace is restored.

    So, now, the $100,000 question: Who is more likely to be selected from this year’s group of unprotected players if the draft does take place? Grand Central Mets takes four educated guesses:

    C/OF Chris Suero

    Suero has experience in the outfield and at first base, but he’s primarily a catcher, and a catcher who hits 18 home runs and steals 37 bases in his age-22 season, even if it’s at Double-A Binghamton, is worth a look.

    His average last season was terrible (.201), but his on-base percentage was solid (.347) thanks to a 16% walk rate. His 106 wRC+ was a big step down from the combined 140 he posted at two levels in 2025. His defense behind the plate wasn’t great (17 passed balls, 11 errors, 23% caught stealing rate in 71 games), but, again, he’s versatile.

    A rebuilding team may see a more athletic Liam Hicks in Suero, someone who can move around in a bench role while he figures out how to hit big-league pitching.

    LHP Felipe De La Cruz

    Welcome to the off-the-wall portion of the evening. De La Cruz, 25, took a leap in his sixth pro season while pitching mostly in Double-A. The ERA with Binghamton was good (2.81 ERA), and he kept the ball in the yard (two home runs allowed in 41 2/3 innings), but peripherals were what put him in this group.

    He posted a 29.8 percent strikeout rate at Binghamton, although his walk rate was 14.0 percent and his whiff rate was 11th among Rumble Ponies pitchers at 32.5 percent, according to Prospect Savant. A mixed bag, to be sure.

    His work in three games and 5 1/3 innings at Triple-A Syracuse settles the debate. He struck out six and walked none, and his sinker, which he threw more than half the time, clocked in at 97.2 mph, according to Fangraphs. Prospect Savant says his velocity maxed out at 99.3 mph. He increased his average sinker velocity by more than 2 mph from 2025, when it was 95.0 mph. He also throws a slider and a changeup.

    To review: He’s young-ish, he’s left-handed and his sinker is quite firm. Why wouldn’t a club at least audition him in spring training?

    SS/2B Marco Vargas

    Vargas has been in the Mets’ organization since July 2023, when he came over from the Miami Marlins in a deadline deal for David Robertson. He got to Double-A in his age-21 season in 2026, and while he missed six weeks in the first half of the season with a recurring wrist issue, he did enough for the Rumble Ponies to signal that he could be a cheap utility player for a needy team in 2027.

    In 53 games, he stole 28 bases in 29 attempts and slashed .282/.363/.407 (111 wRC+). After completing a rehab stint at St. Lucie in early August, he slashed .349/.395/.514 with 10 extra-base hits, including three home runs, in 119 plate appearances. The 30.3% K rate and 7.6% walk rate over that stretch were unacceptable, but overall, he walked 11.4% of the time and fanned 28.7% of the time. Teams can limit his exposure in the bigs early on if he’s seen as a long-term play.

    Once again, the Prospect Savant page is packed with red lines toward the bottom. The speed and baserunning percentiles are bright red at 97 and 99, respectively.

    That speed will play nicely in the field as well. Maybe he can add center field to his repertoire of second, short and third at some point.

    RHP Gary Gill Hill

    A loud section of Mets Twitter will say “LOL, no” to this because he’s not a flamethrower, but Hill, who was part of the haul for Freddy Peralta from the Tampa Bay Rays in August, seems to know how to pitch. He fills the zone despite not having an elite heater, although it should be noted that his fastball velocity maxed out at 97.2 mph and averaged 95.4 mph in his one start for Syracuse at the end of the Triple-A season.

    Here are the combined ratios from his career-high 139 2/3 innings between High-A, Double-A and Triple-A in 2026, his age-21 season:

    CATEGORY VALUE
    K% 20.1
    BB% 4.9
    K:BB 4.1
    HR% 3.0
    GB% 47.7
    LOB% 72.2
    WHIP 1.35

    Also, the bottom half of his Prospect Savant bar chart is deep red. The top half? Tangled up in blue. His overall ERA/FIP/xFIP was 4.26/4.32/4.53.

    The point is, there’s a world where a team could plug Hill into a long relief/swingman role. Even if he’s a high-floor/low ceiling type, that strike-throwing should play for someone.

    The obvious counter is that the Rays and Mets have already given up on him. But go back to the late-season velocity. Look at the age. It's possible that he figures out how to throw harder while still having above-average command.


    Want to play the role of Mets general manager? Check out our free-to-use "You're The GM" offseason tool and build your own Mets roster!

    Build Your 2027 Roster

    Follow Grand Central Mets For New York Mets News & Analysis

    Recent Mets Articles

    Recent Mets Videos


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    There are no comments to display.



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...