2011 comicbook movies

[Vic Sage]

Rank them in your order of preference. Here's my list so far:

X-MEN:1ST CLASS - ****
CAPTAIN AMERICA - ***1/2
THOR - ***
GREEN HORNET - **1/2
GREEN LANTERN - **
PRIEST - *

still to come --
COWBOYS & ALIENS
ADVENTURES OF TINTIN

[Frayed Knot]

Vic Sage wrote: still to come -- COWBOYS & ALIENS ADVENTURES OF TINTIN

Any chance of Olivia Wilde getting nekkid in this one?

[Edgy MD]

A scale of four stars or five?

1) Green Lantern
2) Thor

[Vic Sage]

Edgy DC wrote: A scale of four stars or five? 1) Green Lantern 2) Thor

5 star scale:

GL: [*1/2 - **] The script was a total disaster, but i actually liked Ryan Reynolds more than i usually do, and they got alot of the geeky stuff right.

THOR: [**1/2 - ***] the Asgardian stuff was great, the Earth-bound stuff kind of lame. Overall, it was a little disappointing for me, but not bad.

[Guest LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr]

X-Men and the good Captain both notched 3/5 stars in my book... but had very different ways of getting there.

[Benjamin Grimm]

1. Captain America: First Avenger
2. X-Men: First Class
3. Thor: First Asgardian

Have not yet seen any of the others. I'll wait for Green Lantern until it comes to cable. May end up doing the same for Cowboys and Aliens.

I loved Cap, and really liked X-Men. Thor wasn't as good as I hoped it would be, but was better than I feared it would be.