I just picked Reggie at random, but let's throw another one out there. This time, I've picked a sure-fire Hall-of-Famer, who's the exact same age, so we're comparing them during the same exact seasons: Ken Griffey, Jr., who was considered by many to be the best player in baseball during the majority of Juan Gone's career. Gonzalez, 1991-2003 424 HR 1368 RBI 1866 hits 1027 R 374 2B Griffey, 1991-2003 443 HR 1243 RBI 1781 hits 1119 R 331 2B Now obviously Juan Gone wasn't as good as Griffey was, all-around. Gonzalez didn't have Griffey's speed or defensive ability. But during the same timeframe, facing for a majority of the time the same pitchers in the same league and the same division, Gonzalez compares very favorably to Griffey.