Doing some comparisons: Ryan Church gave the Mets 2.0 WAR, worth, according to FanGraphs, $9.3 million, while being paid about $3.4 million. Yay! The Schneid gave us 1.1 WAR, worth $5.9 mills, while collecting $9.8 million. Boo! So, between those twos, the Mets got $15.2 million worth of baseballin' for $13.2. A modest bargain. Nothing to brag about. If you count Churchie's subsequent struggles after being moved to the Braves and Pirates, the trade certainly looks worse. It's a philosophical puzzle whether that should count or Francouer's solid 2009 or terrible 2010 should be included or none of that. Milledge gave the Nats 0.0 WAR over a season and a half (similar tenure to Churchie) and accrued about 0.0 WAR, worth about $0. The Nationals paid about $625,000 in salary for the privilege. He achieved some modest redemption with the (again) Pirates, so following the players of this deal to the end of their contracts, rather than their tenures with the teams involved, would probably make it look close to even. But then the Church-for-Francouer trade would be the real steal for the Mets, though I imagine few of us celebrate that day.