I liked it. I wish they closed the circle and returned him to his own world, and maybe to his own music. But I couldn't help the joy of hearing the songs like they were new, with new arrangements — sometimes stripped down as demos, sometimes turned into full assault punk. His "Help!" is authentic because like John (or Kurt Cobain, for that matter), he was having a breakdown in plain sight of the world, and they just wanted more. The funny thing is how John-poor the film was. The music is about 70% Paul, 15% George, and 15% John. They also stick largely to the big singles, when I could have used a "Dear Prudence" or a "Within Without You." I got the idea that they had more trouble securing John's songs, but that can't be right, as the songs all remain Lennon-McCartney compositions, controlled by the same publisher. But hey, even the title song was surprisingly fresh. My wife thought she utterly hated that song, and I've always been, like, "No, Baby, it's just been so overexposed you can't hear it anymore." And she turned to me this time and said, "You're right, it is pretty good." Apart from that, please forgive any prejudice I may have against latter-day pop music, but Ed Sheeran is ... not really an asset to the film. McKinnon was typically terrific, though, and I totally surrendered to the void when we got to that secret scene.