"There's just large swaths of the story they're unwilling to tell --- a problem with most adaptations, as interesting books contain more material than the typical length feature film." Duh! "... the story of his amateur football career and failed baseball career and going back to school in his late twenties is a big part of what's going on. The whole "nuns putting a miracle into the soil" frame story --- I don't remember any of that. I don't recall the special mentoring relationship of the young black player, but it felt Disney patronizing when I saw it." Like your first paragraph, they're not telling his entire life story here. And while one of the HS players was depicted as black, there was no particular "special mentoring" for him. If anything, the white catcher was the one portrayed as his main confidant/go-between. "The great moment of this dude washed up from the softball circuit finally arriving in a major league clubhouse is all ruined by the clubhouse being Devil Ray clubhouse, and the uniforms practically being softball uniforms." Would you prefer it if they changed the team he came up with in order to make the story more aesthetically pleasing? .... I didn't think so. "When he gets to the tryout, after sitting around all afternoon, he does a good depiction of an old-school pitcher stretching his arm across his chest (a technique that's now frowned upon), but when they ask if he needs any warmup tosses, he says no. Huh?" Small potatoes. If you want to tee off on some minor scene the least you could do is mock the 'radar trap' scene; a bit of hokum that not only didn't happen but couldn't.