Ceetar wrote: Ceetar wrote: ..but the guy works hard, and tries his best to compete. Am I really going to criticize that? Especially only 10-12 starts post-injury? Is that enough to say a guy's done? If you're asking me, I'd say that you'll begin by concluding that whatever it is, it's Jerry's fault, and then come up with something, anything, to support your conclusion. Warthen and Manuel never addressed a specific injury. Did Maine go to the trainer after he left? the media circus following that was a mess. "He didn't look right, wasn't throwing hard." is not a diagnosis...where does this leave us? "He didn't look right" is indeed a diagnosis, and sometimes, the best damn one. Because the best managers, in addition to being able to control the clubhouse and understand tactics and in-game strategy, can evaluate a player by simply looking at him, sometimes for no more than a few seconds. Gil Hodges had this talent in spades. So did Earl Weaver. And Branch Rickey*. And Davey Johnson and Bobby Valentine. Remove these guys from the dugout and put them in the scouting department, and they'd surely establish themselves as the best judges of talent soon enough. Maybe Jerry had it last night when it mattered. *General, not field manager.