New York Mets' Biggest Surprises and Disappointments In May

We are almost at the mid-point in the season, and the New York Mets are still trying to dig themselves out of the hole they created during their 12-game losing streak. Thus far in 2026, everything that could go wrong has gone wrong for the Mets, with star players being injured or not playing up to standards being the norm so far.

Surprisingly, the Mets finished with a winning record of 16-12 in the month of May, but it was not pretty. From the high of beating the Yankees in a three-game series to the lows of being swept by the Marlins and Rockies, it was a turbulent stretch of baseball, to say the least. However, while others continued their trajectory from the beginning of the season, some have bounced back and are beginning to put together a nice 2026 campaign for themselves.

Biggest Surprise: The Baby Mets

At the beginning of the season, Carson Benge struggled to find his footing at the plate. Benge hit under the Mendoza line during the months of March and April and appeared well on his way to a trip back to Syracuse. Once May 1 hit, everything began to click. Since that day, Benge is slashing .306/.375/.426 for an .801 OPS. With a majority of his at-bats coming in the leadoff spot, Benge has put himself in scoring position for a scorching hot Juan Soto many times and it has worked out well so far.

Likewise, A.J. Ewing has begun his rookie season in a very positive way so far. Ewing’s glove in center field is often on the receiving end of compliments from Keith Hernandez and deservingly so. On the batting side, Ewing is still finding his footing, but much faster than Benge did in the beginning of the season. Ewing hit .238 with an OPS of .650 in May, pairing that with 94th percentile sprint speed and above-average defense, Manager Carlos Mendoza will take that and continue putting him in the lineup every day.

Also worth noting, Christian Scott had himself a strong month of May. In six starts, Scott produced a 2.79 ERA with a K:BB ratio of 37:11. Scott has only allowed one home run so far this season which is a positive as keeping the ball in the yard was a major issue for him in 2024. Scott ranks in the 85th percentile in strikeout rate at 28.1%, providing reason to hope that this isn't just a flukey breakout.

Biggest Disappointment: Bo Bichette

Simply put, the Mets are not getting their money’s worth so far with Bichette, and they could potentially get locked into one of the worst contracts in baseball if his play continues the way it is. In the month of May, Bichette slashed .207/.279/.297 with a .576 OPS. Since the beginning of the season, the Mets have only seen a few games of the Bo Bichette they went and signed to a three-year, $126 million dollar deal.

While the defense has been better than fans thought, the bat has been much worse. Bichette currently sports a -11 batting run value, which is only in the second percentile among all of qualified hitters.

One thing I have found fascinating about Bichette’s swing is his late load. His body motion and lead leg appear to be set later than most hitters. To the naked eye, it appears like Bichette only gets set in time to be late to the ball on most occasions. So, while his chase rate is high and whiff rate is low, most of that is due to being late to the ball and fouling pitches off.

However, what Carlos Mendoza and hitting coach Jeff Albert can do to help Bichette is to let him know that the results will come. The advance stats show that right now Bichette is only one of the unluckiest hitters in baseball. Bichette’s expected batting average is .279, .060 higher than his current average. In due time, the results should come. Or, at least, the Mets have to hope they will, lest they find themselves unable to get back into the playoff picture.