John Cougar Lunchbucket wrote: My point in this debate iirc, was that Holliday appeared to me to be an unlikely get for Omar who for all his faults appeared to value outfielders who could catch. The impression I had of Holliday then and now is not that he's a butcher, but that he's kinda clumsy. Of course he was a better offensive player than Bay and a better bet to avoid a decline but I'm just thinking if Omar had two outfielders to choose from who were somewhat comparable, he'd choose the one with the better glove (to the scout's eye, not to metrics necessarily) even if he gives up in other areas. I don't know if it was just bluster, but supposedly they did run some internal metrics that suggested Bay would be a good fit. And hell, I thought he was the better sign, they didn't need a super star, just a slugger and the shorter commitment seemed like a good idea. 100 home runs over 4 years would've been just fine. overpaid, but very helpful. Now it's clearly one of the worst Mets contracts ever but this is far beyond even what people against the signing thought would happen.