OK, I'm going to weigh in on this topic having read the early posts about whether or not Diaz was a much better Mariner than Met and if he is or is not trending downward. Once the thread turned into having arguments about the arguments my hair started to hurt and I tuned out. OK, so there is an outlier season for Diaz but it was more 2019, his first in Queens, than it was 2022. This certainly isn't news to anyone here, we all saw it and it was bad (made worse by the fact that Familia was at least as bad). So while I'm not trying to deny it happened, I am going to toss it aside for now and see how the comparisons look without it. So the chart below shows Diaz for his 3 seasons as a Mariner; line 2 is Diaz as a Met minus that 2019 season and the 5.59 ERA; then Edwin's entire NYM career (3 full seasons plus 2 partial ones) on line three. GIPERAWHIPERA+H/9BB/9K/9HR/9 SEA1881912.641.021566.13.014.20.9 NYM - 20191661672.370.991695.73.315.20.6 All NYM2322253.201.091266.53.315.20.9 What is clear from the above is that, aside from that one season, his NYM numbers are as good or better than his SEA numbers across the board. And even with 2019 included, having the worst season in what was essentially the mid-point season of a career doesn't make anything a trend in either direction. Also, hitting your nadir at age 25 and then bouncing back doesn't indicate anything resembling age related decline. Now, is he a reduced pitcher on account of the year-long injury? Is the pitcher he's been so far in 2024 the one he's locked into going forward? While both are possibilities, it's FAR too early to know that and I certainly wouldn't base an answer on the 16 innings he's pitched this year. The disturbing part so far, which I mentioned during Monday's IGT, is the HRs. But, again, let's wait and see. 4 HRs in 16 innings is close to the same pace as his 2019 15 in 58 but to call them the same now is to somehow know that this is a trend locked in place and life and sports don't work that way.