Mets' Deadline Fire Sale Continues As David Stearns Sends Brooks Raley to Phillies

Three relievers down, how many to go? After a late-night trade that sent Huascar Brazoban to the Chicago White Sox, David Stearns clearly woke up with some urgency. Brooks Raley is now on the move, and he'll be staying in the NL East as he joins the Philadelphia Phillies.

Though the destination is a little surprising, the move itself is anything but. Raley is a rental reliever, and much like A.J. Minter before him, was better suited to help a contender down the stretch than the Mets. Meanwhile, the Phillies recently lost Brad Keller for an extended period of time and have been in desperate need of a quality left-handed set-up man.

In return, prospects Luke Gabrysh and John Spikerman (incredible name) will be coming back to New York.

Raley, 38, has been a fixture in Queens since 2023, his first season with the team. He's pitched to an incredible 2.31 ERA over 149 appearances in that time, including a 1.96 ERA in 41.1 innings this year. He's as soft a tosser as you'll find, but he uses his flat arm angle to create an unmistakable advantage over opposing hitters, emerging as one of the best contact managers in the league. Though it'll be hard to root for his success in Philly, he'll always be remembered for an excellent tenure in New York.

As for the prospects coming back, Gabrysh was the Phillies' 15th-round pick in 2024 out of Saint Joseph's and is regarded for having three pitches (fastball, slider, cutter) that all have plus potential. It shouldn't be too surprising, then, to see that he has a 29% strikeout rate in High-A this year. The problem is that he poses incredible reliever risk, due to poor command and some concerns about his ability to turn over lineups multiple times. He's started 36 of his 39 pro appearances thus far, but the 23-year-old may benefit from a shift to the bullpen.

Spikerman is the more notable prospect, ranking at No. 27 on MLB Pipeline's list of the Phillies' top prospects. He has absolutely no power to speak of (zero home runs, .078 ISO this year), but he's still got a .753 OPS and 116 wRC+ this year thanks to a mature plate approach and decent bat-to-ball skills. More importantly, he's an elite base runner and plus outfield defender, which gives him a very solid floor as a potential fourth outfielder at the major-league level. He just probably won't emerge as more than that.

It's a reasonable return for an aging rental reliever, featuring both a high-ceiling and high-floor player. The package will likely be easier to appreciate once the Mets wrap up the deadline and we can assess their entire haul.

View our top trade candidates list, up to nearly 70 names and updated regularly!