Mets' Trade Deadline Gamble on Billy Amick Was A Bet Worth Making

The New York Mets were clear sellers at this year’s MLB trade deadline, and one of their earliest moves was dealing reliever A.J. Minter to the Minnesota Twins for some prospect help. Among the returnees is a farmhand by the name of Billy Amick, an infielder who is having an unbelievably impressive season. Let’s dive into what he brings to the table, and how he may be able to help the Mets down the road.

Billy Amick's Updated Mets Scouting Report

Amick is a 23-year-old corner infielder prospect and is one of New York’s newest up-and-coming talents. The Mooresville, NC native played his college baseball at the University of Tennessee and was a member of the 2024 College World Series winning squad. After spending a pair of seasons with Clemson, the third baseman held a potent bat with the Volunteers in his one and only year with the group. 

Amick made a profound impact in his final collegiate season, thrashing 23 homers with 65 runs batted in while slashing .306/.387/.639 for an impressive 1.026 OPS. That campaign was enough to make him a second-round pick, as the Twins selected Amick 60th overall in the 2024 MLB Draft. 

A Power Surge In 2026

The third baseman made plenty of progress in 2025, climbing from rookie ball up to High-A Cedar Rapids, but this season, he’s tapped back into the power many saw at Tennessee. Amick is slashing .224/.341/.502 with 26 home runs and 80 runs batted in over 91 games played. The powerful third baseman is on pace to eclipse 30 homers in just his second full season in the professional ranks, and his .842 OPS shows this is someone who can be a problem as he makes his way up the minor-league ladder. 

A Closer Look At The Damage

It’s one thing to hit a ton of homers, but let’s take a look under the hood to see just how productive of a batter Amick is. The 23-year-old is getting out in front of the baseball plenty, logging a 28.6 percent pull-air percentage, good enough for the 93rd percentile in Double-A. Building off of that, the former Twins prospect is also putting the ball on the ground just 28.6 percent of the time (96th percentile).

Someone who can lift the ball to the outfield consistently can move runners over instead of eliminating a pair of them in one swing. On top of his power, Amick has also made for a consistent on-base presence, drawing a 13.2 percent walk rate (73rd percentile). 

Room For Improvement

While the third baseman has generated plenty of opportunities, whether it be from a clobbered baseball or one of many free passes he’s earned this season, the Mets up-and-coming infielder still has his faults. He isn’t chasing out of the zone much, yet Amick has 38.6 percent whiff rate (8th percentile). Cross reference this metric with the fact he’s swinging at 68 percent of offerings in the zone, and you get a 72 percent zone contact rate that’s one of the lowest in all of Minor League Baseball.

Amick has the right idea; he’s swinging at quality pitches, but he’s getting fooled on pitch type/location. No matter how powerful he is or how often he gets on base, it'll be tough for him to make a mark while he's striking out in 30% of his trips to the plate.

Expectations With Mets

While Amick is far from perfect, the pop and potential are there. The Mets have struggled mightily at the plate this year, and their slugging is a big reason why; New York is 24th in slugging percentage (.387) and 27th in OPS (.692). If Amick keeps these power numbers up and can cut down on the swing and miss in his game, he could be a perfect in-house solution to that problem.

Interested in learning more about the New York Mets' top prospects? Check out our comprehensive top prospects list that includes up-to-date stats, articles and videos about every prospect, scouting reports, and more!