1. Richie Ashburn 2. Duke Snider 3. Willie Mays 4. Gary Carter 5. Frank Viola 6. 7. 8. Mike Piazza 9. 10. Pedro Martinez 11. Paul Lo Duca 12. Francisco Rodriguez NOT QUITE RIGHT: Bobby Bonilla (first Met season 1992; first Met All-Star selection 1993); Dave Kingman (first Met season 1975; first Met All-Star selection 1976); Johan Santana (first Met season 2008; first Met All-Star selection 2009); T#m Gl@v!ne (first Met season 2003; first Met All-Star selection 2004); Al Leiter (first Met season 1998; first Met All-Star selection 2000); Bret Saberhagen (first Met season 1992, first Met All-Star selection 1994)